Three times he gave the wrong call on knock-ons and deprived us of possession - twice on their line and one on ours that resulted in a goal line drop out. The two on their line were both blatant and he was right on top of them.

Otherwise one of Smith's better games. Which isn't saying a lot, mind.

dont think he was too bad apart from a couple which looked a bit harsh and i thought from a giants perspective he let hull hang on a bit too long in the tackle, but he certainly didnt change the outcome of the game

tbh i was more interested in what hull were doing then the ref

i think he let both teams get away with quite alot tbh

Don't think i vented my spleen once at the ref which is rare. Spent more time will my head in my hands watching two poor team try their best to look crap, obviously we won in that department.

i think you are being very harsh to hull fc, or are you just bitter you lost?

granted we should have posted a few more scores on you, but we did a proffesional job last night, if you're squad can't control the ball, that's not our problem

I'd have given you more credit if you had beaten us by a decent amount rather than 4 points. To say you beat us by 4 points when we played garbage doesn't say much for your guys. We'll both need to improve(and i think we will) if we are to do anything this season.

I thought Hull were poor TBH so I think you'll likely finish in the bottom 3 on that basis

oh well, i guess good teams get dragged down to a lower level at times

Very true mate. We've played some good rugby against the top teams this year so far. Playing you teams from the bottom last season makes it hard for our boys to lift ourselves i suppose!!

That's you 4th from bottom then

yes, it must've been galling for you losing last night, after beating bradford away, stuffing the french in their own backyard, pushing the mighty saints to the wire, you must've been expecting a walkover!!

the scoreline didn't reflect the game, 1-17 man to man we won in every department

I'll echo that !!!!

the scoreline didn't reflect the game, 1-17 man to man we won in every department

I was expecting a very good game due to both our starts this season. Unfortunately we didn't play anything like we have done but i'm guessing you've also played alot better than that this season.

we have, and we still have room for improvement, 4 from 4 while not hitting top form is a good sign

You read their forum during the week, then?

Despite the eventual score line, I think anybody watching would say that we were never really in any trouble. If there is fault to throw at us it is that we didn't kill the game by moving up a gear and perhaps taking our gas of the peddle once we knew we had won in the last few minutes. The score line didn't reflect Hull's dominance. That said, I don't think we were quite as good as we was against Catalans.

Saying that, I don't think Hudds fans have to much to worry about, things didn't come off last night, but you could clearly see the potential, creativity and desire that won you the game at Bradford.

'"

Is that how they won last week with the same ref

Last week you beat Bradford by just 4 points and it one of the weekend shocks

So that make Bradford a bad team then

So you don't want credit for that game then

I've said many times on our forum that the Bulls have seen their best days. They'd have beaten both of us on last nights showing though.

You`ve really taken last nights result badly haven`t you!


Maybe Hudds are just been overhyped?

Yes I took it badly. Our team shouldn't be losing to teams like yours.

I wondered if your reputation was deserved. I see it is.

check the past superleague meetings since we both came up, you will see that we shouldn't be losing to small a team like yours