Did they affect the result at the end of the day? Do you think if those tries were dissallowed we would have transmogrified into a different team?

I've got to agree , That pass left Hulls 10 mtr line and the winger caught it 5 mtr's out .

No but heads drop and all that.

What a word that is!




I think there's a world of difference between going in at half time at 12-0 and going in at 22-0.

half time score made no difference on full time result in my opinion

Agreed. If those tries had been chalked off, they'd have scored at some other point. They were all over us from start to finish.

Suppose we'll never know

Sure it was an old Red Dwarf episode

To be honest you need to watch it again on the last replay angle. Additionally you can't use released and caught distance markings as a judgement to whether a pass is forward or not.

I can use my own fecking eyes though.

You cart even go down the momentum rule as O Loughlin was pedestrian at best.

Your Agar out thread is fair enough.
Don't you think it's time the BOD were replaced. If Agar is so obviously that bad then it's the BOD's fault for awarding him a two year deal.

You have coach after coach and you are going nowhere. Yours is a great club and this game needs a strong HullFC but I don't think we are going to see it with this crew in your boardroom.

The number of Hull juniors that make the first team is massive and very impressive. They don't appear to improve though.
From an outsider Horne is no better than in his first season.
Yeaman and Washbrook haven't improved and Hall has gone backwards alarmingly.
Your BOD need to thoroughly address the coaching at SL level so your juniors do improve. The board don't seem capable of doing it though.
Management is about making it happen and yours isn't and won't.
Agar should not IMo be your first target, it should be your board.

How does Wigan being excellent paint over cracks???

If we'd of nicked it in the last 10 i could see your point.

Bolloxs....you would have beat us anyway without that pr1ck giving you a helping hand for some of your trys............

What's even more alarming is i can't disagree.

So we get rid of the board,who,for the past 5 seasons have made a profit and twice we was at the bottom of table.........we cant knock the board for the way they run the club as a buissnes but they are accountable for giving us crap coaches.

I was there and it looked a mile forward at the time, when i saw it at half time on the tv it didn't look as bad to be honest.
Was it forward? Yes, did it alter the game, IMO no.

But thats the fun with opinions we all have differing ones.


What i find most comical about this thread is seeing certain posters who were backing Agar last week now back in the Agar out camp.

They wont budge !£££££

At least we're consistantly disagreeing!

And why should they???????

Sooner have them running the club than fans.

I want winner's mark , And that for me starts at the top . Some of these need to take a look at themselves and see just see why are they here .Are they here for the right reasons.

You can still be a fan and run a business as well.

Cough...Hudgell...Cough

I want us to be winners but not at the expense of the club...that has happend too many times before Steve.

See Wigan and Warrington for examples.