Blanch, Farrar, Sa, Stacul, Bosc, Dureau, Ferriol, Henderson, Casty, Menzies, Raguin, Mounis, Baile, Vaccari, Simon, Martins, Baitieri, Pelissier, Pala.

Briscoe, Dowes, Fitzgibbon, Horne, Houghton, Lauaki, Lyne, Manu, Moa, Obst , O'Meley, Phelps, Radford, Tickle, Turner, Washbrook, Westerman, Whiting, Yeaman.

Sharp dropped, Washy back in 19.

Will do Sharp's confidence a great deal of good that will.

1.phelps
2.lyne
3.turner
4.yeamen
5.briscoe
6.horne
7.obst
8.omeley
9.houghton
10.radders
11.tickle
12.westerman
13.fitzgibbon
subs
14.lauaki
15.moa
16.manu
17.whiting
but could see whiting on the wing with washy or dowes on bench and if moa dosent make it then dowes on bench

right decision for me.....under perform, you get dropped. Let him build his confidence in the reserves for a couple of weeks.

It will take him out of the firing line thats for sure and give him chance to regroup and work on a few things in his game that little bit harder. He should come back determined to make amends and not let it happen again.

Thats of course if he is professional.

Spot on.

I hope so.

www.thisishullandeastriding.co.u ... ticle.html

www.thisishullandeastriding.co.u ... ticle.html

If he brings Whiting in on the wing then it's a terrible decision, either play Lyne or put Whiting at FB and Phelps on the wing.

right decision let him play 20s for a couple of weeks take him away from the pressure and build his confidence again, i personally think he will go with lyne on the wing but im not sure

Bang on the money.
Especially considering both their wingers are about 5'7". But very fast.

Play poorly get dropped. Do you suggest we reward mistakes?

Don't fancy whiting's chances in a foot race with either

Not suggesting anything. Just suggesting it will knock his confidence. However, like has been said, it may take him out of the firing line and he could come back a stronger player. If so, then good decision.

All depends how agar is managing it. I'm sure he's explained the reasons to the player

I'm sure he has too. Agreed

. How long until he is back in the side? Derby? Wire? Saints? Suppose it all depends on how Lyne/Whiting do in his absence and how he goes in the U20s.

One dodgey winger for another.......Whiting to centre,Turner to wing.

I don't fancy Whitings chances in a foot race with me.

Now you're just being ridiculous

Yeah, you're right. He'd have fecking no chance.

Hes a grown man for godsake..im sure hel be ok!

Hes not playing well so its a justified decision..a few more kids should be thrown in for underperforming players.

Id start lyne he deserves a crack.

whitings positional awareness will keep him 2-3 paces in front of the wingers when they're attacking our line and he'll tower above them when we kick to the corner ?Also he'll tower above the wingers if they kick to our corner .

Really? Is that why we've been shipping tries on his and sharp's side all season?

Don't recall much towering going on last season when he was on the wing either. Francis Meli certainly didn't have a lot of trouble at any rate.

Playing whiting on the wing says everything about agar's mentality