Lots of talk about agar clearing out the deadwood at the end of the season but are the deadwood? Suppose it depends how you define deadwood

The players off contract are:

Byrne - already gone but hardly deadwood
Thackray - possible deadwood but probably our best prop over the last month or two
Cusack - similar to byrne, not spectacular but deadwood?
lee - not the greatest player in the world but bags of effort and improving
whiting - one of the most consistent performers in the team but would he be a starter if we're at full strength?
Hodgson - surely can't be described as deadwood
Tony - one of our best players last season before his injury IMO
thorman - dead as wood can be but only been here a season so can't really be considered as fundamental to the problems at the club
g horne - averageness personified
maloney - looks a good prospect. SHould have had more gametime IMO
moa - waste of an improt slot

So the ones off contract can hardly be described as deadwood IMO. Unless by deadwood they mean players who are just average in which case tehre are some but not enough to fundamentally change things around unless they use the spare cap from this season to get rid of the likes of dowes, king and radford

i have highlighted the players i would keep in bold and i would keep probably dowes next year but would let go all other players

i'd say Radford and G Horne are definite deadwood

the squad only needs one of Dowes or Cusack

Thormans so rubbish he's more a peice of MDF than actual wood

and despite being a fan I think Tony has a lot to prove in the next few months.

Maloney and Moa also have to prove themselves but with their salaries being low we could keep them for another season at least.

Whiting - 2 year - quality player
Maloney - 2 year - looks to have a lot of potential
Hodgson - 1 year - untried
G. Horne 1 year - utility

Would also keep Thackray for another year as there aint that many better available props to replace him with.

WTF??? Thackray is our only genuine impact forward and you wouldn't offer him a deal.

and you would offer a deal to another utility player in G.Horne??? When we should and rightly so be signing whiting up

As I said I would offer Thackray a deal.

G. Horne I would keep because he is a steady player who can cover a number of positions, every team needs utility players

Tansey and Whiting will provide the utility next season so i think G.Horne will leave.

Would definatley keep Thacks,Maloney and Lee.

Yer but in the backs we would of lost Tony and Byrne and replaced them with Tansey. So I think we need at least one more back just incase of injuries like this and last season.

When agar says abouting clearing out the deadwood does he include himself in that statement????

Deadwood-
Cusack
Radford
King

Get rid and replace.

To leave.......

Tony

Hall

Cusack

Horne G

Thorman

King

I think 8 will go

That's 6

Look I do know addition is not my strong point



its the other two I am unsure of



Radford ?

2 spare slots for head and assistant coach

To leave:

Byrne
Cusack
Tony
Thorman
G Horne
Moa
One of Radford/Tickle
King

Retain:

Thackray
Lee
Whiting
Maloney

Possible:

Hodgson (I've not seen much of Hodgson so I really don't know what potential etc he has)

that is a good starting point, but we would probably replace with driftwood

My players to be released if they are to be replaced with top quality are

Thorman
Radford
Horne G
King
Cusack

I couldn't comment on Halll, Maloney and Moa as they appear to out of favour with the coaching staff, and don't get to play that often.

King
Radford
G Horne
Cusack
Tony
Thorman

Dont think Thacks will be too bothered,to be honest he as more than one club who will definatley take him on in superleague.Noticed something about Thacks,never seems to get injured and thats why other teams will want him.But we always seem to let players go what want to play for us,nevermind are loss someone elsies gain

Yet when we signed him (1st time round) people moaned because he was "injury prone" (2 broken arms in a year at Cas IIRC).

Thats one of the reasons id keep him for another year, although he blows hot and cold, he is 99% of the time available

Yes correct but how many times since 2004? none as far as i know.Hes been dropped but never injured.

pretty sure thats the case (I was agreeing with you btw in the last post).

Let go of,

Motu
King
Whiting
Cussack
Hall
Radders
Thorman

hall and whiting,dont think so the rest by all means