Anybody else really happy with the progress he's made since getting settled in the squad? Looking like an injury free Dykes to me.

Massively underrated cos his name isn't Thurston or Marshall. Doing a great job for us.

Ordinary, in my opinion. Well, maybe that's slightly harsh, but he's no better than 'good'. Not a patch on Dykes for me.

I like Seymour! I think because he doesn't add much of the wow factor in terms of runs and steps he isn't getting the recognition he deserves. He does make the wrong decision sometimes in terms of his passing, but 9/10 times his passing is very accurate and he organises the attack well + defensively i rate him.

Better with him than without him, so that says it for me.

Desperately needs a decent stand off along side him.

Was poor today imo, cost us two tries due to poor defense

needs a six and a full back who can join attacking line

he's no Dobson!

We're better with him than without him because he's the best scrum half we currently have at the club. That doesn't mean we don't need a better one to challenge for silverware.

One who could put his shoulder in and tackle consistently would do me, he couldn't even tackle Washy today!

Good post.

He was garbage today,both in attack and defence and his kicking game was shat,apart from that he didn't do to bad.

P.S Don't even get me started on Westerman.

yeah,he actually played a few games in the nrl...

His defence is normally decent

just goes to show it's not the be all and end all eh!!!

Terrible individual error on Washbrook which was miles below the required standard. That said once again he was the only channel with the ball as Ellis proved beyond doubt that he's miles out of his depth at this level.

I'd take good every week over very good once a month every time.

Yes I know but was very poor today

Average at best, but better than we have had in recent years, which tells you how woeful it has been.

We need quite a few things before we can challenge for silverware, a replacement for Seymour is not in the top 5 IMO. As I've said before, if we sign a 6 of the right standard I think may well be good enough anyway, ATM there's just too much for him to do alone.

Agree with that, but ability wise they're miles apart, IMO.

It might not be in the top 5, but I think it'll become necessary before we're serious contenders. Unless, as you say, we sign a world class 6, then we might be ok.

He'll look like a world beater alongside holdsworth next year

Bigger problems than Seymour