After your wins against Bradford, Hull KR and now table toppers Warrington, I think Agar could be in contention for coach of the month. Would you be happy for him to pick up the award?

I would be happy if pi$$ takers didn`t come on here.

I'd like Agar to get it it means Hull are winning and that's all i'm bothered about.

for all the crap hes had laterly,and i am one who has had a pop at him........id like to say well done mr agar.........

If we turn Saints over next Monday he'll probably get it, and deservedly so.

Even though the games in May?

He probably deserves it more than any other coach in Super League, he has guided us to three quality wins against a decent Bradford side, Table toppers Warrington and then beat the Dobbins.
No other coach has been under as much pressure as Agar either, fair play to him.

Concessions are allowed as long as we beat them.

Of course, the flip side is that we struggled to beat a poor Bradford side thrashed by Salford just a week later - the winning try coming from a complete miskick when Horne went for a drop goal.

This was followed by a poor effort in losing to Catalan, when they'd lost every other home game this season.

We then made a meal of beating the worst Rovers side to show up in the Super League era, with them in turmoil thanks to their clownish board and the Mason debacle.

Month rounded off by a decent win against a good side.

Won't win Manager of the Month for April but I'd like to think that this month is the springboard to better things and maybe a run at Manager of the Month sometime in the near future.

What I am pleased about is that Hull been getting the rub of the green after some woeful luck earlier on. Defo evidence that luck evens itself out

I think it was initially a Friday April 29th game.
I wonder if it still counts as an April game for the award?

I think Trent Robinson will win it myself

Agreed, 4 wins and a draw this month for Catalans, and deserving of the team/coach of the month

In fairness they were on a roll having had 2 fantastic wins. I for one didn't expect us to go there and win.

I'm sorry but he still has a lot to prove in my eyes as FC's coach. Two wins back to back does NOT in my opinion excuse the usual standard of dour rugby and the feeling of going backwards as a club in recent years! We are a massive, well supported club and we should be making massive strides forward within the game. Everything is in place and has been now for a while but Mr.Agar for me cannot take us any further forward. He should still go forth in a gyrating motion for mine and lets get a top proven coach in who can (A) Get the best out of a pretty decent squad which we are, and (B) Play open expansive attacking rugby with more than one poor option in attack!

Surely the cats coach who won at wire and wigan and also beat agar's Hull will get it?

I'm hoping agar gets coach of teh season award folling our cup and GF double

It's a fine thread these things hang on though Jakey?

Beat by our neighbours and in my opinion we'd have lost to Wires and Saints and Rich's position would have become untenable.

Don't make him anymore depressed than he already is.

Couldn't agree more 2 defeats over Easter and this week would be a whole different kettle of fish on that score.

He'd have been history, simples.

Give himself a shot now, and fair play.

If I ever feel depressed I dig out that old thread where you claimed sam obst was tansey's replacement

That's the nature of sport though. If we'd won the games against wigan, wakefield and cas then he wouldn't have been under pressure. It's a results business

Tansey was back up to our halves, now Obst is. Its not difficult.


Anyway, I think the thread you tried to claim there's no such thing as luck trumps most things even I could come up with.

Really? Show me some scientific evidence that luck exists

Did obst go to FB yesterday when phelps was injured?

I have been a harsh critic of Agar. But i have to hand it to him, in the post-match press conferences and interviews he sounds calm and collected. I'd be delighted if he won 'Coach of the month', but more than that i'd be a whole lot more delighted if i realised the last three years were all part of some grand plan and i'd been wrong about Agars coaching abilities.