i know he isnt getting the rub of the green and he's lacking a proper centre partner but to me his heart doesnt seem to be in it, i hope im wrong... thoughts ?

Tend to agree,always appears to be in front of his centre, need Raynor back ASAP

Thought he had a good game again....every pass he gets his behind him,he works like hell in defence which has improved...we have a problem with our centres as neither of em know how to pass.

i think calderwood has been playing e. he never seems to be on the wing where he should be. and whenever he does get a pass hes in frount of the ball not running onto it. had high hopes when he signed for us but a big disappointment up to now.

Why do you think Wigan got rid ?

not getting decent service is the problem IMO same as it was for Blacklock and Sing, all 3 are/were proven try scorers, then they go on FC's right wing and get the ball once a game.

he always has that disinterested expression, has done for his whole career, the only other expression he has is 'cocky ' when he's scored a few!

I don't think Raynor would have done any better or different tonight, neither wing got a good ball.

we don't even utilise his pace with a kick to the corner either

More like he is over running the play. He is lacking in confidence for me. He does not appear to be part of the team. I could be wrong, but he does not seem to be fitting in with the rest of the squad.

wonder what will happen when raynor is fit, cant drop briscoe because he's on fire... id be tempted to let briscoe have a crack at centre to be honest with it being his natural posistion

He is cack. There isn't really a place in the modern SL for the skinny lightweight winger anymore.

Threads not about the other winger, but if want my opinion Briscoes playing better

That's 'cos he constantly mis-times his runs. This is happening every match - Horne and he should have it worked out by now.

That said, I think his heart is in it, if anything he's trying too hard, hence the eagerness to be in front.

Sorry, but I disagree. Considering the number of times in a match he receives the ball in an attacking position, I've got no complaints with him so far.

You should know by now that players called Briscoe are beyond criticism on here.

Didn't see him do too much wrong tonight to be honest. Has he got Blacklock syndrome.

Calderwood received only one decent pass and should have scored when he was one on one in the corner but got pushed in touch.

How can we judge him when he doesn't get decent ball?

If he stood a bit deeper in the attacking line he would improve 100% he is just too flat and at best he is level with the centre but a lot of the time he is in front.

He should of scored in the 2nd half as he should have dived much quicker but tbh he hasnt had any decent service tbf, I'll wait until the ground gets harder before i judge him

Been saying that all season,

He's rubbish

Bit harsh Jake. He seems to be lacking confidence at the minute but to call him rubbish is OTT imo.

It'd be interesting to see Briscoe feeding Calderwood, definitely, but I don't think Horne should lose his place.

FFS give the guy a break. Some people have had it in for him before a game was even played.
He has had very little ball, no real decent passes and yet it's all his fault.


He's been solid in defence and willing to help the forwards, taking the ball out. Lets give him some credit and stop knocking him, hardly going to build his confidence that.
And to that idiot in the East Stand shouting abuse at him, get a life and support our players.

You will be crying after the Derby when we have kicked to him . All those High balls can't wait .

In Australia he was like a frightened rabbit caught in some head lights .

In the Derby, Crocker and Laukai will crush all your players