Ok.........its a good debate and one for me I am glad we are having for far too long we have been hit my the injury curse and just managed to put a patched up team on.

Just to put this into the mix, this week its Castleford and with all due respect the bigger game is the week after at Wigan. So what do we do rest a key player?
Or stick with a winning formula??

I dont know the answer thats why I am a fan and not a coach. But I want to win both please. The team spirit is there for all to see the reaction to every try was fantastic.

I don't think Briscoe should be dropped, he has done very little wrong. He needs to work on his positional play granted but he has worked hard in defence and with ball in hand.

I don't think that he "deserves" to be dropped but if anyone "has" to be rested, then he is probably the only one that could be slightly criticised for his last two games. He has been caught out of position or poor under the high ball on two or three occasions which all resulted in tries. There was also a close call in the corner against the Quins.

If we were to split hairs, he would be the only one that I could find slight fault with.

That's pretty fair!

1 Whiting
2 Calderwood
3 Hall
4 Yeaman
5 T. Briscoe
6 Horne
7 Tansey

8 Radford
9 Berrigan
10 O'Meley
11 Tickle
12 Manu
13 Fitzgibbon

14 Houghton
15 Lauaki
16 Dowes
17 Moa

Unfair on Turner maybe but I had to find a place for Tansey and we'll need him with ball in hand a lot. Moa in for Cusack, just don't rate him. Houghton needs a big performance too.

1 Whiting
2 Calderwood
3 Hall
4 Yeaman
5 T. Briscoe
6 Turner
7 Horne

8 Radford
9 Berrigan
10 O'Meley
11 Tickle
12 Manu
13 Fitzgibbon

14 Tansey
15 Lauaki
16 Cusack
17 Moa