Looking at the topic on Tansey and Briscoe as to who is the best, who is the most over rated player do you think we have ever had. I will keep it to our team as I dont want it to become a cross river slagging comp.

exactly.... all three have played massive games for australia and SOO.....anyone who plays in them teams isnt over-rated in my opinion.... you have to earn them jumpers without a doubt.....those teams dont pick themselevs unlike the GB squad......
if sing and berrigan were playing for saints or leeds for the last two years then sing would be top try scorer and berro would be a shoe-in for man of steel....

thank you kind sir

Sing was not overated, just way past his best. And I watched him regularly in his prime, live.

hunte worst signing for me.

In recent times, Berrigan has done nothing for us and needs to prove us wrong next season.

to be fair to him, Sing was one of the best players ever to come to hull , however we never saw it because he had a lot of bad injuries, was never playing outside anyone who could feed a decent winger and to be fair he was a tad past his prime in a very average side.
still thank him for playing on with injections masking injuries other lesser players would have sat in the stands with !!
but certainly not ever over rated

Poor Crooke. . . Oh sorry, I thought it said 'over hated.'