I don't comment on games that I don't watch but I can comment on the result I see and games I listen to what through a bias radio station, you cannot take anything positive from a loss and a big loss at that

We failed to score against 12 men. I mean come on

We played a Leeds team missing two centres, one wing and the scrum half but they managed to beat us. We played a Wigan team missing two centres and a winger and they managed to beat us. The views reported by some on here are not just based on one, two or even three games but nearly two seasons worth. I would be happy if we had just lost the first three in isolation but we have lose 38 many of which were in the same manner.
I admire your loyalty to the club but unfortunately the club are stretching the loyalty of many supporters with the performances on the pitch.

Quote ="Luppylad"There you go https://www.bbc.co.uk/sounds/play/p09dxyhj'" I don’t know why they don’t use the same interview each week because they have all the same excuses other than he blames different players. This week it was Hampshire, a winger and Woods, I think he should look in the mirror and ask himself is it him.

Quote ="Luppylad"There you go https://www.bbc.co.uk/sounds/play/p09dxyhj'" I don’t know why they don’t use the same interview each week because they have all the same excuses other than he blames different players. This week it was Hampshire, a winger and Woods, I think he should look in the mirror and ask himself is it him.

Saints were without 5 of their first choice 17 - Percival, Knowles, Lees, Mata’utia & Smith. They had a guy sin binned and we got a hell of a lot of decisions our way first half. We never looked like scoring, just like we haven’t all season other than some individual efforts. Our kicking game is dire, despite the bigging up of our NRL signing. Whilst i admire your positivity you need to stop defending the indefensible and burying your head in the sand because the signs are there, we are dire and we are in trouble.

'Full left side missing, which is our attacking force'!
Give over, living off one stella season from Tupou, when he passed.
He's a winger and would be better with Arundel as his centre.
Too much loyalty to players, irrespective of how they play.

On the 5th May 2019 we beat Huddersfield by a point, 26-25. Since that date we have played a further 40 league & cup games against super league opposition and won 8 of them.

I’m sticking to what i’ve said for the last couple of weeks, Chester has until the end of the month to turn it around otherwise with the cup break it is time to walk. He needs damn good performances against Hull & Catalans with at least one win out of them or for me his position becomes untenable.

Unfortunately the Wakefield job is a coach killer. For numerous reasons such as, we don`t have a ground worthy of Superleague , a salary cap to match the other teams in the league or a sugar daddy backer who can afford to throw money in without thinking twice about it. A lot of the squad we have have been on the rugby merry go round before arriving here and the local talent we have nurtured is not coming through compared to other clubs, maybe because we haven`t the strength in squad to let young players play out wide and get used to the speed of which is expected of them. When they come in they are straight on the coal face expected to do the job. Yet still theres statiticians on here who can tell us our win to games ratio and come up with the conclusion that its the coaches fault. No coach sends out the message, come on lads lets get our s kicked for the supporters. Sometimes you have to admit that we are being beaten by a better set up team than ours.

you can't blame the ground for poor performances and poor attitude on the pitch it would match any club, that's where they apply their trade and yes no coach would send a team out to play bad but the team could if they have no faith in him and don't want to play for him, if they aren't then they are making a very poor job of it

I think its part of the problem PT, a lot of us were expecting what we got because we get the same every week and that's regardless of opposition, regardless of who we have out as a team, regardless of circumstances - We lose games in the exact same fashion with the exact same problems that lead us there. That's just not the first 4 games of the this season, which a stated all look very very similar, but all last season and the season before that too.

We seem to have this conversation every week with regards to, we were missing this player, we were missing that player, we had to switch this or that around when in actual fact zero changes regardless of who is out there, that's just been real. It made me laugh that then radio commentary team last night credited saints for blowing us a way in a 10 minute period but here's something for you, if I ask you to cast your mind back to last week you would get something very similar against Catalan, could just be a coincidence but look the week before against Wigan? Exact same, what about the week before against a patched up Leeds? Near identical.

And after all that if you still think it's a coincidence or anything to do with missng players or our opposition, you can probably go through yourself last years games and realise that the worrying trend was something that was there all year long regardless of who was on the pitch, regardless of who was in front of us.

I stand corrected it is 8 wins in 40 v sl opps quite surprised that the agg score is around 28- 16 which for the high amount of defeats aint that bad

Well for a win against either Hull or Catalans, we would need to see a completely different team and attitude - similar to that displayed after the press slagging last season. What happened to that attitude and positivity? How come that same passion is not applied now?

Would love to know what the half time motivational speech is ( steady lads you don’t want to be knocking yourselfs up or you’ll get on nose bleed) . I just can’t imagine what is said to instigate performances so different in two half’s .

I will put it down to the Grix facter..For the first 10 minutes of the second half We switch completely off.instead of playing safe

I watched the whole game last night and the first half we put everything in we defended well and saints didn’t really bother us and we had plenty of field position but quite simply we just have no idea what to do with it even when they were down to 12. Still we went in at 0-0 and thought who knows if we get a bit of luck we could hang in here. Then we come out like a completely different team, I don’t know if they switched off or it was the team talk but we just disintegrated and crumbled like a biscuit. We we’re falling off tackles for fun.
Saints got on top in the forwards and it just goes to show that if you do this it creates the space for the backs. We look so easy to defend against and even with our power in TJ and bill we play the same way, we can’t apply any pressure on our opponents cause we can’t score any points and the effort we put in all’s goes to waste add to that it’s an 80 minute game are we fit enough, well the pack should be they only play 20 minutes each half. I suppose if you can’t see the problems you can’t solve the problems. Effort 100% know how 0

Snowie. I know the ground will not directly affect the players performance, but the bigger picture, is that a player would more than likely choose the better ground facilities and stadium over a derelict ground that needs updating.

I'd agree with that.
It's not a fitness thing, or an effort thing
It's quality of both coach and players.
Personally I think it's less coach and more players.

If we can improve our attack we will improve our stamina in games because we do less work and make them do more.

But, if we are not able to play half our strongest players, the quality will dip, no matter what people want to believe.

Ask yourself this, whilst he's not without faults if Kear was in charge of this team would you have expected only 8 out of 40+ wins?
IMO Kear would be doing significantly better with this team. I do not think it's an effort thing with the players in the main and ateotd the buck stops wit the coach and we seem to be going only one way now.

Personally I'm worried. Very worried

Let's be honest. The same people moaning now moaned about Kear too.

In answer to your question, I don't think he'd have got much better out of a 3/4 line of Innes, Lyne, Arundal returning from injury and Kershaw.

People are constantly talking about the team not performing as well as it should but the team that can perform better isn't on the field.

For the record I didn't want Kear to leave so would be happy for him to come back, but if he does he'll instantly have 'fans' moaning that we play 5 drives and a kick.

If we can improve our attack is the million dollar question is it not?! I know it's only 4 games, but what improvements from last season have you personally seen so far? Has our go forward, kicking game, execution of plays, last tackle options, defending opposition kicks, creating and taking opportunities when the opposition are making errors........have they all improved? I would say a big fat noooooooo. The very first game against Leeds, our star player & coach in their after match interview both said, we are still making the same mistakes as last season......

That’s not answering my question is it? Would we have had 8/40+ wins under Kear? Yes or no?!



And there is a difference between people moaning and other people pointing out Chesters deficiencies

Chester has been given long enough to prove he can turn things around. He has been given the players he wanted and two new assistants to help him and still we cannot put a structured attacking plan in place. He has in all honesty got far more assistance than probably any of our coaches in the SL era. I actually think our line defence is better but how much is that down to Chester.
What do you want the supporters to do accept the obvious that relegation is currently on the horizon and be happy that it’s worth it because the club is showing loyalty and will not face their responsibility and remove Chester.
The people in charge must see the performances and realise what relegation means for the club. They want us to keep spending our money which the hard core will but their numbers are reducing and SL is in the entertainment business and we are certainly not.
When the crowds return if we continue the way we are I am sure that the club and Chester will be fully aware of what the supporters think both vocally and with reduced numbers.

Just watched the highlights. Saints looked like they were playing a totally different sport to us!

That's a very difficult question to answer with any degree of certainty as well as being a ridiculous one, conveniently chosen to back up your opinion about the coach, which is more down to the fans moaning and not specifically pointing out his deficiencies.

I agree pop tart ,it’s not fitness or effort which is in a big part is down to the players themselves,but our attacking structures are woefully inadequate and has to be put down to coaching. Until we get that sorted I’m of the opinion that whoever we sign won’t make a jot of difference until we either have a game plan or at least implement one ,and don’t get me started on the half time team talks .We have a quality squad that may not make the top 5 on a regular basis but should be able to go toe to toe with them all and not crumble like we have done so far no matter who runs out for us .when we get on the opposition line we are simply devoid of ideas how to unlock that defence.We revert back to one out rugby far too often. These are the basics of rugby league and are played out all over the north on a weekend by amateur clubs ,but we find it so difficult to do this.We may not be Melbourne storm but we certainly are a much better outfit that what Has been on show for far too long now .