Oddly you're wrong on this or at least historically wrong.

Roe's assistant McNally took over and saved the day - Tony Smith, McNally's No 2 did exactly the same a year later when McNally was sacked. Tony Kemp did strangely well when AK bit the bullet though he wasn't his assistant. AK himself I think came through in a similar way as did John Harbin. The only obvious bucking of this trend was JK an external appointment but dire though our situation currently is it's not yet as bad as that was.

All had instant if short term success. So in theory at least it's very much the way to go - whether it works for us yet another time is a worry as we may be pushing our luck but hey what choice do we have.

We need four wins for security IMHO and you'd hope a new broom might just manage that.

If youre telling me that Tony Smith was a success then we really are screwed. Within a year we were relegation fodder, although I take your point about the short term bounce affect in 05. Either way my point remains, it's a high risk strategy, one which is effectively saying it doesnt matter who we change to as long as we change. I don't agree that's anything other than high risk. You say what choice do we have? Is there really nobody at all out there? Or do you think it is just financial?

Well of course I'm not and you've confirmed that in the rest of your post. Short term Smith was a huge success at the end of that season, if Webster does the same I'll be a very happy man. I'll face next season - next season.

If the new coach effect works temporarily and we start picking up points that will do for this season. We can worry about a new coach in the off season.

If however there is no change and London get their first win, I'd say we'll be looking down both barrels and will be fully deserving of it. We've had enough chances already to be well clear of 12th spot.

If you think back to 2006, we weren't that far off the rest. We weren't going to finish bottom, that was Catalan. We were in the mix with Wigan until they bought Fielden, and with Huddersfield until the Teapot game. Our problem was that we let other teams pull away from us. This year, we are stopping ourselves pull away.

The irony this year, in the context of all previous "RFL hate us" theories, is that the RFL might save us, with the Bulls appeal.

I would be most worried if I was a Salford fan.

The galling thing is the tweets from within the camp about how great Agar is, as if somehow he has been hounded out of his job, when it's the players who have let him down!

Agar confirmed he was looking for another job within the game so let’s stop the ‘hounding out’ propaganda. His time at Hull showed no matter how much stick he received, and that was far greater than what he got here, he would stick to his guns.

All accurate but in my opinion does not alter the fact that we have appointed a coach with no SL experience and who is tainted with failure. That to me is a high risk strategy. I'm not saying he will fail because I've nothing to judge him on, he might end up the next Wayne Bennett I've no idea. I just don't see how appointing him was the right thing to do at this stage. Obviously I hope he does well and I wish him luck

Don't go for the hounded out bit myself, someone correct me if I'm wrong but didn't RA resign as he wanted to look for another job? I'm guessing he's got a job lined up already and wanted to walk away from his contract, so hounded out my arris.

I don't think he's been hounded out. That's not what I meant. Just from some of the tweets from the players hint that they feel it, when perhaps they should look a little closer to the mirror. That's what I meant.

I'm sure your right jinjer there's no way supporters have forced him out of the job he's got summat better lined up that's for sure not done it to please us

Bang on my old mucker!!




If he had wanted to stay, he would still be here - of that i am convinced.
I didn't quite get the context of the MC tweet about listening to fans and expecting 17k supporters for the london game, Agar left because HE wanted to and has something lined up.
Not that i'm complaining of course, i just wished if he had been talking about it to the BOD for a good few weeks (about going), he would have gone before the Bulls game.

Agreed, at least Agar did the right think and stepped down. I dont think he would have been sacked for a good while yet.

Hopefully we will see a response from the players post London game but there is still a worry that Webster like Agar is well into the club and not sure if there will be new ideas ? Hopefully that is the case and we can post 4 wins before the end of the season.

Mick Carter has said it would have been costly to bring in a new coach, new staff, new physio and conditioner etc and I see his point as long as Webster can get a responce.

I do think though that at the end of the season we should be looking at a new coach regardless of how it ends (firm believer of coachers/assistants and 3 year cycles).

I think we should be looking to bring in Noble 2015!! At least wel beat Salford twice a season

If he ruffles a few feathers, drops those not performing instead of favouritism to a select few and starts getting performances AND results he'll get my vote. I say we give him a chance, let him pick his own team and see how we do. What used to get my goat was Agar putting players back in after injury messing with a settled side and the excuses became tedious after we got tonked. I'm looking forward to seeing his first team line up, new man, new ideas, there will be some, surely?

The most interesting thing for me will be to see who Webster pick in the halves.

Not sure as to wether he jumped or not. If MC is a friendly with RA as he suggests then he might have called him in and said "mate weve got to make a change" it would sure make his quest for another role in the game easier if he left his last post "of his own choosing" rather than being sacked, so there is a strong possibility of jumped before pushed. Don't know - only those in the know will know.

Lol. So he's been absolutely crucifide on here and Facebook and Twitter for months now.
But when he resigns, "it's nothing to do with us gov" "We didn't do anything wrong"

I'm pretty sure the pressure from supporters had an impact on his decision. Whether he reads them, I'm certain the spirit of the message works it's way back. If not to him then to MC and KH. It's bound to add to the pressure.

I reckon he did the right thing for himself. He did a decent enough job but it was going own hill rather than up and I'm sure that makes life stressful on top of the usual stress of the job.
Many others would have seen out the contract and made us pay to remove him. He gets credit for that from me.

Whether he lost the team or not, or didn't get the support he needs, he has been man enough to accept the position he is in and walk away.
I wish him the best for the future.

You would hope he could turn to his 'senior' players but that might be the problem.

I don't think he did a "decent enough job" - I thought he did a terrible job with a talented group of players

I agree with most of your post, apart from the last part (about Noble)
Can you imagine the furore on here if the club had spent a fortune and still had the same impact as a slow puncture.
Salford spent big, primarily on Nobles say so and the team that he assembled looks comfortably like the most overpriced squad in SL history.
Sorry, although Noble has without doubt been a superb coach in his time, it would appear that he is beyond his sell by date.
Having said that, I've no idea who we should go for.
Rowley, at Leigh, is doing a superb job but, he's just signed a 3 year deal, maybe Karl Harrison but, please let us keep away from the other Agar type coaches, who talk great but don't appear to have the man management skills to get the best out of a group of players.

No it was a load of cast offs who he turned into a talented group of players.

Some of them were talented cast offs.

Haven't seen much talent yet scarlett

Should of handed your CV in and applied for head coach.

They wouldn't be going on holiday this week

I would of thought they wouldent of gone now, if so next week Id be having them in everyday