Yeah but I can think of many games that we have unexpectedly won thanks to his all round performance.

It will be a big loss if he goes, one of the best scrum halfs in the league, not easy to replace.

harelequins home last year?

lets face it the general opinion now is that danny b is going, so id let him go now if a deal is available and pocket the cash, play bj at his best position of sc, let sam do stand off, and rotate newton and latu at 9

???

and that coming from last years danny brough defender on here!!!!

I'd be gutted if he left. He's easily our best player.

Get bloody signed Danny!!!

actually in my opinion now hes isnt
but thats based on past performances from mr S Tronc

hope he brings his A game cos if he does its special.

I would give Danny a dead line for signing and if he has not by then I would list him and get some money for him. We cannot be held to ransom financially by one player.

thats fair enough but why do you think a club would pay for him when they know they can get him on a free transfer next year, but by the sound of what one of your other posters has to say the deal has already been done with the giants. he is a very difficult guy to keep happy is broughy and from what i can see he is pretty much doing to you what he did to cas but he did get us back into SL so i don't bare him any grudges.

Yeah but if a club really wants him they could be prepared to pay a transfer fee instead to see if they join the queue of clubs to sign him at the end of the season...

That could be an interesting option, it might make someone squirm if there has been a deal done in secret whilst under contract.

Who is his agent by the way?

Brough was pivotal in our top 8 finish and would only have improved our chances of beating Catalan if fit. That said he's no Gaz Ellis and we survived him leaving, just, so it's over to Danny...

if he goes i hope it is to huddersfield, would happily take robinson off their hands. players come and players go. if we can get a fee for him brilliant. he is not the saviour of wakefield just another part of the team. remember when solomona left, everyone saying wakey would sink without him.

well?

westwood,wood,ellis, solomona, atkins, brough?

if he goes there will be someone to take his place. the club should not break the bank to keep him

Cant believe im going to say this, but i mean it, id list him now!!!

the deal is as good as its getting, he isnt signing so lets cash in, wed surely be looking at more than 150k looking at the warrrington deals over the summer??

Whilst i'm a great fan of Danny Brough, there are many players out there who given time can replace him. The upside to keeping Brough is obviously he is English, An a product of our academy. But that said, no one player is bigger than the club.

I'd hope the club has set a limit they're willing to offer and they won't budge. Let's keep to our cap and ensure we're not paying over the odds. As others have said, players come and go, the club will remain

Robinson is gash.

could not have put it better myself, apart from adding the word "complete"

Agree completely, would be funny if he did go to "improve his chances of winning silverwear" and then by some miracle we won SL, i know it will not happen but it would be sweet.

would not pay him out in washers

Would rather take Brown myself, just the sort of player Kear could work wonders on, would have Brough before the both of them.

see id take brough going for brown and cash and see if brown could play stand off again with BJ (clubscapegoat).

intrestingly in brough stays and "informed thinking" is hes leaving watch how quickly he becomes official club scapegoat!

Scapegoat or not I think even BJ's biggest fan wouldn't back him at 7.

if brough plays like he did boxing day then he will deserve the scape goat tag, time will tell.

well to be fair it where he played his best when here last!

i think if broughy does leave you will really strugle to replace him with a player even half as good unless you go to oz and pay out a fortune, but on the other side of that if you do list him now it will probbably just upset the camp and to be honest every club he has played at including you now if rumours are to be blieved it has not ended well so in my opinion it would be a big risk for any club to come and pay a big fee for him but if he goes on a free transfer he is much less of a risk to a new employer and you might just get a good season out of him if he knows he is already sorted at the giants for next season.

And his worst.
His only option is stand off for me as a slightly better Rooney/Martin.

So do we go back to the title of the thread?
with or without the cash.

sounds like that deals a non starter now with or without cash.