Of course they should but you'll always get a different view/version form board to board and we can all be blind at times.

Just go on the Wigan board and read some of the blinlered guff on there mate, thats the way it is.

Anyway "what forward pass" i never saw it

and if he gets a ban it will go to show that we have been hard done by in the game, I can get over the hock forearm but this has touched a raw nerve

absolutely shocking what he did never mind saying he didn't do on purpose, this could of been nasty

It sure could have, Scully moved his head just in time.

Suprised Scully did not knock 10 shades out of the little so and so

he should of, never mind size he came over as a spoilt brat and should of been put down a peg or two

I think latu still had him in mind at the end

Agreed, he would have only got what he deserved.

www.sportinglife.com/rugbyleague ... Wigan.html It amazes me how they can find him guilty... yet he gets away with a fine that'll make no difference to him whatsoever... If it had of been a Wakefield player......

www.sportinglife.com/rugbyleague ... Wigan.html It amazes me how they can find him guilty... yet he gets away with a fine that'll make no difference to him whatsoever... If it had of been a Wakefield player......

The RFL really do despair me at times, they really do. With Tomkins getting a fine for demonstrating his karate technique on Sculthorpe, he's gonna think that behaviour is as acceptable is Gareth Hock punching a defending player rather than fending off...

Oh wait, he plays for w*g*n, simple enough reason/excuse/cop-out...

All this he plays for Wigan if it was us e'd have been hung drawn and quartered is bull. We've had players up before th beak this season who havehad warning letters etc. If he'd have caught scully fair do's he'd have been banned. He didn't and has been warned and fined, fair cop for me. I'm sure his coach will have a word with him about it and I doubt you'll see him do it again, therefore, lesson learnt. If he carries on doing this then thats where the problem is. Basically it was a young enthusiastic player going a little too far, nothing more nothing less. Get a grip people.

AS I said on the VT, Scully to be banned for two games for illegal use of the face. How dare we criticise Wigan's new golden boy.

Correct. Also it was the first time he has got done for anything as well, it's not like they where going to ban him on his first occasion! He was fined £300 which i imagine is quite a lot to him (unless Wigan pay it) if it happens again he will get a ban.

If Kyle Bibb had done the same, should he be banned?

Its not just here.

I have just seen one of the worst decisions in my life in the Souths v Bulldogs game. Unbelievable!