Look I have been on here before and stated that "Trinity"are my second club,and you are all entitled to your opinion's,but I have got to say that list of so called over rated SL player's is inaccurate and surely the poster's cannot be serious.Many of you had that kind of opinion of big Ali before he signed for you

How can it be innacurate?



Its peoples opinions that you disagree with, that doesnt make them innacurate!

James Roby for me, i think he is gash. An embarrasment to the game.

I wasn't one of the many I can assure you, but if you ask many Cas fans they will say he has been over-rated (funnily enough after he snubbed them to join us)

Because I cannot believe these opnions are serious

It is possible to have innacurate opinions.

You are massively overreacting.

The thread wasn't entitled, 'Most over-rated player in SL and their relative quality when directly compared to the equivalent WTW player.'

Calm down dear.

To be fair if people have been saying Sinfield thats pretty stupid to say he has made leeds the team they are today, even at international level when getting played out of position at hooker he has done everything asked of him and more. For me i would say Josh Perry, hasn't lived up to his rep stature.

Agree on Perry, an aggressive lump with not much go forward.

Don't you understand, opinions are subjective

Jeez, if this topic is so (sigh) upsetting.

Don't read it.

That is all.

I guess Monday night seals it for Webb!

Rangi Chase - yes I'm being serious..had one good season for Cas (last year) did hardly anything before and hardly anything after apart from a flash of brilliance once a game his passing and kicking game is atrocious and his defence is pretty much awful apart from the occasional "shot"

And we all know how that turns out...

Precisely.

Don't think you can class Webb as being over rated now. The whole RL world now rates him as past it.

On current form I would say Wilkin has picked up the gauntlet.

have you read any of his self interest fuelled offerings in the press?

I would Huddersfield giants have got a team full of them

Kyle Amor with the love in thats going on about him on this forum lol

Weller Hauraki.

no, Hauraki is not rated at all,but Cas and Wakey are in competion for him next season

I'd heard something similar - hopefully he'll go be attracted by the bright lights and star signings at Cas.

steve southern

He's useful on his day.........sadly his day has never materialised whilst at Leeds.

None overated by me, some are better than others, simple as that, it should read who does the two idiots from sky overrate ? I like most make up their own mind throughout the season.

O'Louglin, however is not beyond overated, he is a 150%er in every game, and by far the best 13 in SL, and would walk into the Wakefield side with ease..