Not in the same class.

Sean isn't fit to lace up Jason's boots! Both in terms of character & potential and ability as a rugby league player.

ok whatever you say. The stats would suggest otherwise but i did not expect any support for my choice on a Trinity site.

I agree JD has been a great servant to the game and Trinity, and is having a good season, but is that enough. For me his best chance came a few years ago, when he was superb can't remember which year it was maybe 2005 or 6, but i would not complain if he did get it in truth.

I think he may be in with a fair shout, along with Bevaer for us and Dobson at HKR.

Who

think he means

Fa'asavalu

Nice beaver...

Stop it!

Agreed, he has been terrific in most games for us this year - but had a lull when he appeared to be playing with an injury. I would probably have him behind Snitchy for the Wakefield MOS award.

2007 was (by far) his best run of form in my opinion, head and shoulders above everybody else in our side, and most others in the league. If he wasn't seen to do enough in '07 I dont see how he can be realistically in the reconing this time round.

The Beaver : Steve Menzies.


Sorry about the mispelling at the start.

still it is a nice bevaer

I've seen nicer beavers.

I think Olivier Elima should be in with a shout. He's having a great season for Catalans so far.

Beahave!

it may be unpopular, but I would go for Keith Senior this season, a wonderful player, and like we witnessed at home, still the best centre in the comp.

No one likes a show off!

On topic don't think you can really consider JD for MOS his chance was a couple of years back and he missed out. Will probably go to Cunningham for his boxing qualities!

like others have said, if he missed out 2 years ago he won't get it this year and is probably behind a couple of our own players.

I think Puletua, Chase, Webb, Gidley and a few others are in with a shout

I believe it´s JD´s leadership off the field under tremendously trying times this season that sets him apart from all the other contenders mentioned,warrented as they are.

The three best players I have seen this year, in the positions they play are

Hodgson the Hudds full back

Stephen Wild

Earl Crabtree

No wonder Hudds are having such a good season. If they stay injury free I tip them to win at Wembley and reach the grand Final.

You won't make many friends on here syaing things like that.



Seriously though, I do tend to agree that they have been a much better and more consistent side this year. Whether they have enough in them to win the CC and get to the Grand Final remains to be seen but they won't be far off.

Probably won't win the MoS but I really like Catalans' Jean-Phillippe Baile. Wish he played for us.

Jd's time for winning the MOS has passed. He had his best chance a few years ago when he ripped up the SL, brett hodgson could be a gd shout for hudds though.

The stas are pretty even between these2.Is it the Opta stats that you are referring to?
Cheers

Not really, and it certainly backs up the fact SL is fit to lace JD's boots.

S.L.
Position 13
Shirt number 13
Appearances 18
Tries 5
Try assists 9
Goals 0
Drop Goals 0
Meters 1475
Carries 215
Tackles 640
Offloads 18
Attacking Kicks 24
Runs from dummy half 15
Tackle Busts 27
Marker tackles 95
Clean Breaks 9
Forty twenty 0
Kicks in general play 35
Missed goals 0
Missed tackles 36
Errors 18
Penalties 16
Red cards 0
Yellow cards 0

J.D.
13 Position
8 Shirt number
20 Appearances
2 Tries
4 Try assists
0 Goals
0 Drop Goals
1612 Meters
263 Carries
601 Tackles
10 Offloads
26 Attacking Kicks
80 Runs from dummy half
70 Tackle Busts
73 Marker tackles
4 Clean Breaks
0 Forty twenty
31 Kicks in general play
0 Missed goals
46 Missed tackles
23 Errors
18 Penalties
0 Red cards
1 Yellow cards

Nice stats...