I'd rather see Lyne in the team than not. He's a bigger threat than the rest of our backs with the exception of Johnstone.

It's interesting now they've starting the dream team what prices each player costs
Arundel £120000
Lyne £115000
Tupou £105000
Gibson £85000

Cant agree. Gibson looked our best centre till his injury last season and our purple patch was largely with him and Arundel as our centres as I recall. None of our centres are ideal in my view. Some have strengths where others are weak but Gibson looked the most rounded player to me

This preseason I would describe him as flat.

I do agree Gibson is good but he was only a short part of the winning run.
Didn't he play against Hull (after Arundal got injured I think) and was then injured in the next game against Widnes, when Tupou came back in for him.

I may have the exact number of games wrong there but it seems to have been forgotten how well we handled our centres being injured one after another through that period. We did pretty well handling it compared to some teams who just bemoaned their losses and used it as an excuse.

Lyne lacks confidence in hjs ability at times he needs to work on his positioning in defence though as that side of his game is lacking though he can tackle quite well.

I think he gives 100%. I like the lad. I am just a bit sad to say, I just don't think he quite has it at SL level. He does for periods of matches, maybe even a match or two now and then but he is never far away from being badly exposed in defence or spilling the ball in a key moment or field position. Those depressing walk-in tries that we see on our flanks are very often his bad defensive position or premature bad decision. And he does not appear to be learning much. I thought he had it the season before last. He had a good run for a few games but then it was back to usual. Vey hit and miss. I think this season is his last chance with us for me. If he keeps getting caught out I would let him go.

Well he wasn't playing on Sunday and the problem was still there.

That was Gibson, Finn, Batchalor, Caton Brown.

By far the best centre we have got rate him!!!