I wonder if Carter has a nice new job waiting for him over the common when Wakey go down and bust. It would explain the sucking up he has done to Steve Gill recently.

Five tries down Tansey's wing. I don't expect to see him next week or indeed in the middle 8's.

Difference in the second half. Cas realised how we are out wide.

Poor, very poor. The kind of performance I thought we'd seen the last of. Miller gone back in his shell. Smith not on his game. Lock injured.

6 tries down Tansey's wing.

Conceding 50 against Cas again is dispicable. These players don't have any professional pride whatsoever. Can't think of any player on that pitch who serves to play super league again.

Another embarrassing capitulation I see. Whilst I hope we can survive the 8's I can't say I feel we deserve to.

You do talk some utter sh111te

No way will you go down, cannot see it at all. There's too much class in that squad - that 1st half was some great stuff from your forwards.

Lyne, tansey does not work. Matt Ryan for me at centre. He can tackle and would do a far better job. Riley/ryan or Lynne/Ryan.

How has smith still got a gig never mind replacing Miller who had found some form at 7. It's about time we wake up on smith. He's been dire and shouldn't set foot on the field for us again.

Positive wise, arundel, walker, mullalley, Simon and Johnston.

Smith needs to decide on his top 17 and play them I think now. That game was a disgrace.

Just one note, the ref allowed a lot of wrestling today which cas had down to an art. Also the play early second half where cas player fell to floor ball carrying arm first and ball slipped out given as a strip was awful (again) which opened the floodgates.

I guess Tansey/Lynne decided they didn't fancy tackling the pudding that is Carney. Thought we controlled the game for alot of the first half, second half was an embarrassment. Some of these players (not all of them) just don't wanna know, when the going gets tough

and that's what might just get us relegated.

Conceding almost sixty points today proves we have no class whatsoever.

That was a massive step backwards. We ought to plsy in fairy costumes considering powder puff strength of most of the team.

Also the inability to do the basics right from so called professional players is disgusting.

When locke went off why move our only attacking threat to full back?

Finally, why did we not pick our best 17 considering tget need some cohesion before the middle 8's

TBF I'm fearing the worst for triniy relegation is calling . crap signings have killed us tim Smith can go asap .. Utta garbage

Both Tim Smith and Reece Lyne showed again today why neither of them should be anywhere near the starting 17

Rubbish the pair of them

Who are the best 17 Tricky? Brian Smith might have thought that was his best today, we don't know that. I would certainly have Ryan, Ashurst, Sio and Godinet when fit in the squad but that's just me. He's given them all a fair go in recent weeks but to me we've gone backwards with that second half today. We'll just have to hear what he has to say in the post match interview and then see what happens at Hudds.

Maybe Cas were very good!

They are near the top of the league for a reason & they were playing a team still in pre-season.

Sounds like that’s it for Locke though

.

You missed the two half chances that Johnstone converted into scores then?

The view from the end is not the best to make a judgement but I thought the lads down the middle did okay but were badly let down by the jokers out wide, specifically the right hand edge. That was were the game was lost.

Some pudding though. I have noticed that Paddy Flynn at Widnes always seems to get the better of him.
To be fair he does take some stopping when in full flight.

I'm not sure why conciding 50 "against Cas" is anymore embarrassing than conceding 50 against any other team. Indeed, conceding 50 to Cas (a team pushing for top 4, who finished 4th last year and made the cup final) is less embarrassing than conceding that amount against many other SL clubs.
I hope you are back in SL next year, a local rivalry is good for both teams and provides a good financial benefit to both with a high attendance. I would much rather see the back of Salford.

I was waiting for that

Well I would never have guessed that after your continuous bile on the Reds Forum!

Indeed, Cas are as good as any of the top teams on their day.

But regarding little old Salford, you really need to let the Rangi thing go

.

Since he’s gone, Cas have gone from strength to strength.

On the plus side at least our capitulation didn't happen in the first 15



.

I have barely posted on the Salford forum in the last two years. Others have been far more critical than me.
I merely entered a debate around how they managed to get Chase a visa after Hull FC could not, and against the guidance of the UKBA.
I admit that I would love it if they didn't actually get the correct visa when they signed him, as seems to be the case with Paterson.

Quite frankly it just wasn't good enough over the 80 minutes. Matched them up front for parts of the first half but made way too many errors and as soon as Cas gave the ball some air we were all over the place and unable to cope, it harked back to the dark days of Webster in that respect. Tansey and Lyne were ridiculously poor on their side. I suppose one positive is that Johnstone might have added a couple of quid to his value with his double. BS has a lot of work to do yet.