As long as we don't need L Smith as a half back

That's true but we are not comparing like for like. Hall may have been a class act at HKR but Smith played 150+ games over a 6 year period for a Championship winning side and was never far off England selection and has the medals to prove it. Hall has never been anywhere near that. I think we forget sometimes that being at a top 4 club gives you a head start before you take anything else into account. All things as they say are relative.

Was Hall a class act at H K R or just a steady Eddy.

Well 'class act' I suppose is really a matter of opinion. Let's say he has creative qualities, like I said before, he just isn't, for some reason, using them for us.
Of the two, give me Smith, I was a bit gutted when he left!

Lee Smith has played 4 times in 2 years for the Falcons he must be 20 stone of pure fat. If we can get him in radical shape then maybe!

Well then, what does that make you?

Where on earth do you form these opinions?

Clueless as ever

would I not be right in saying he was playing with us two years ago

You would indeed be correct.

so the comment by newgroundb4cas is again rubbish

Is the Pope Catholic

Do bears shyt in the woods