If Walshaw does not play the next game it is an absolute travesty. He caused the giants problems in attack with some good offloads thrown in and was rock solid in defence. Well done Lucas

Even I will be critical if he doesn't keep his place.

Yep great game Lucas Walshaw , should definitely start next game.

I cant remember but someone on here was fighting the corner of Walshaw at centre?
Who was it ? Wait it was me! Proven correct once again.
BEING BIG DOES NOT AUTOMATICALLY PUT YOU IN THE FORWARDS!

Walshaw will probs get a few mins against Hull if hes in the 19 that is.

Completely agree with the last few posts....from what we are hearing from people who went he's had a cracking game.......reacted exactly the way he should have done after going out on loan....

Got some game time, got his chance with a few injuries....been match fit and slotted in and taken his chance with both arms.....serious questions if he doesn't play at Hull.....well done Lucas....great attitude!

Yeh I liked walshaw before today and he was great today made yards every time he had ball in hand

+1

Take a bow Lucas , did all that was asked of him.

One thing I do know bren you say I drone on about my superier knowledge well I know for certain when it comes to youth rugby from 16 onwards your not in the same class 'you've given your opinion on wildie and walshaw I've seen em both as academy players and I've seen our current crop,the 16s have looked impressive but if you do know about young lads youl know the next 2 to 3 years will tell us shoes gonna make it with the right coaching of courses lot of attention as been forecast on young jowitt looks a decent prospect , but I saw the Bradford u19s winger run over him twice and yet some on here want him to play super league'no chance not in the same class as wildie and walshaw or even southernwood at that age I've said it before when I was coaching pro clubs couldn't approach players until after 16i assure you I had the best players in Yorkshire mainly until 17 the likes of Jason Robinson and Paul newlove and if we produce lads like them we'll do well

Another laughable post by the genetic clone of Frank Stanton and Wayne Bennett, bigging yourself up again at the expense of a young kid, shameful.

Naah! Not much

No really

walshaw was good today looked a handful as did ryan, and sammut was his usual, brilliant one minute awful the next the other 17 were pretty average.

Expected from you mate but reading your posts you know nothing

Which posts, about what?

Good to see. Must the expert coaching he's had whilst out on loan...

There's only you laughing,and all of em that I've read

Not trying to big myself at a kids expense at all ,think jowitt could be an excellent prospect don't think he's ready for super league yet just trying to answer bren comments of wildie being a rotation hooker and walshaw a big steady lad, the fact that at the same age wildie was an international halfback tells me that with the right work on him he could have been developed into a super league halfback,and as a coach you rub your hands when you get a young lad the size of walshaw then find he can also play the game can't wait to turn him into a long striding centre or secondrow

That's the point I'm making - he [icould[/i, but he hasn't, and the reasons for that are worthy of discussion; I think he's been let down by successive coaching regimes but I have no idea at all if it's now too late for him. Can you teach an old dog new tricks?

LW has probably just secured a deal at the Giants for next year.

matty was a cracking young player. in the time i coached him at wakefield we had him playing in the halves he was playing ok but he was beating himself up with his kicking game, he was taking too long to think about things and driving himself mad. we moved him to hooker so he could build his concentraion levels and have say less time to think. hes a good player and could easily go back into the halves needs managing properly.

Problem is his accent - if he spoke fluent Aussie he'd get half a season to prove himself.

I'm sure potentially Harry is a better player technically - but it's Wildies future at stake and I'd be tempted to back him.

The only down side is that as yet Wildie has not played that binding game that says he's arrived and the clock is ticking a bit. He just seems to lack the self belief of a Brough or even a Kyle Wood which is a worry.

Would serve us right - I can't even be bothered to blame them any more we make it so easy.

Liam Finn seems be relishing SL after being in the wilderness for years!

Finn got lambasted on here by the "experts".

I sad he was a potentially good signing and would be an asset to Cas and so he has proved to be. I'll leave it to Cas fans to say how good a signing he's been.

That said if we had of signed him our Jester of a coach would have played him at prop so his non signing was probably no loss to us at all.

Can't say how delighted I am if this lad is proving the RL snobs wrong - whilst we carry on with our Penrith reject.

Walshaw was Wakey`s best player by far yesterday.