I wouldn't mind the first time he was on telly he wasn't that bad

Think it was just a stop-gap, because Klein went to Aus with virtually no notice. Maybe Halibut was the only one who could take a summer off work (other people can empty the bins at Le McDonalds for a few months). He might be gone next year.

James Child- was at the KC last night. He has done severla non Sky Tv games in the middle- about eight I think this season

I think he had a good game last night, most of the ` mistakes ` were when he was unsighted and went to his touch judges who either gave him a wrong decision or offered no help. I felt sorry for him on the Brough knock on. He clearly made the right call waved play on, wakefield ball back another set of six. Then I am sure Ganson, the fourth offical was in his ear telling him he had made a mistake and he then gave Saints the put in at a scrum.

Only found fault with him for the JD holding down penalty. All refs make mistakes, its a very tough job, I just wish they got better help from the touch judges.

hes a poor ref but i do not go for this bend ref thing he gave poor decisions for both teams

Bent ref? No, the man wouldn't know how to he is a complete joke! Just poor all round

He is simply incompetent and out of his depth.

Yes, he made some bad decisions against us, no question - he also made some bad decisions against Saints that were in our favour.

When he refs other televised games not involving us he makes bad mistakes in those too.

He is not bent against us - he is an embarrassment to all teams that play the game.

To say one thing about alibert he told the saints players who were protesting about JD after the Grix try he told them that JD led with the palm of his hand not his elbow...he got right..

We wont mention the number of times they were not standing square then, or the number of obstructions' that he failed to see. Just one more thing out of many others which you failed to observe last night, when they knocked on and we picked up the ball if there is no advantage it should be a scrum I lost count of the number of times we lost 10 metres' or so when he waved play on. You have just contradicted yourself by quoting Ganson correcting him on one of his many mistakes you said he did not make. And of course all refs do make mistakes they are only human the difference here is that most refs are qualified mentally this man I am sure knows the rules inside out but his inability to put these into practise and also to control the game is alarming.

We may have been on the wrong end of the penalty count last night, but what impressed me most was the way we just got on with the job and didn't get riled. Broughy looked like he was about to lose it when he got pulled up for the "knock on", but managed to control himself (though he had a face like thunder when he was picked up on camera). Saints looked more bothered by the reffing decisions than we did, tbh. We showed a lot of maturity last night. Job well done.

the biggest and mistake was probably his first one when the saints player picked up the ball from an offside position, we had a number of players around that could of picked that ball up and gone on to score, it could of been classed as a professional foul and a sin binning, also a penalty try could of been allowed

exactly right.

gareth hewer and jamie leahey (spelling on surname?) to name but two...

the frenchman isnt 'bent', he doesnt show favoritism, he isnt biased....he just struggles with refereeing in general. he made some awful decisions all night long, 3 massive ones early doors went against us...but after watching a replay, there were some that the saints fans could feel just as aggrieved by!

either way, he needs dropping from SL

He missed a offside by Wakefield aswell, when the ball came off a Wakey player and was picked up by a player in front..

The ref , touchjudge and SKY commentary team missed Francis Meli diving forward from the defensive line and knocked it forward causing the Wakefield player to knock on. Which is when Danny 'lost it' and gave a penalty away. The idiots on SKY just went on about Wakefield players talking back not the knock on he missed.. it was just after half time

Snowie I have just watched it on sky+ he was not only poor for us but on occasions did the Saints no favours either. Absolute incompetance

I'm going to endure it all again tonight

Talking about the idiots on Sky personally I was sick to death hearing how much the Saints team were depleted, no Long no Eastmond etc. We were without Drew, Martin, and Blanch not once did that get mentioned in the same context as their missing players'

What a shame, come to work with me tonight then

I thought the same, amazing!!

would love to where we going anywhere nice

But they did mention Saints still had 11 full Internationals in their 17.

get used 2 it when we beat them 2 weeks ago(salford)it wasnt how we played well it was the fact that st helens where very poor and missing players.

well I'll see u there then!

i dont think he will be hear next year

well I've just finished watching it again and can't believe they still allowed wellans to kick


Albert wasn't as bad the second time round in fact I could kiss each cheek

garlic permitting, what is standoutish is the quality players that saints have just not in the game, pryce, jammer, wilkins and roby it looked like cunningham trying to take us on this own, no wonder for the aggressive punch on stostic

the magic moment of the game was blaymire's tackle then smothering of the ball by peto

Make yourself known in Perpignan then!