Just watched this Webster will now have his work cut out.Gilmour to old get rid,Riley poor,Owen garbage,in fact the whole team were.

Bad day at the office.

Irrelevant about the outside backs.

Game won and lost in the forwards today. Collis may be back next week so Lynne could go onto the wing?

Exactly, a bad day at the office - so why are you calling for heads to roll? I was expecting a beating in France, admittedly not like the hiding we got today, but no need for major surgery imo.

I wouldn't move Lyne from the centres on his current form, besides Collis is a right centre and Lyne plays on the left.

Couple of points

It looked very humid and the players looked to be suffering from that.

Why on earth play in a black kit in such heat basic physics is that dark clothing absorbs the heat whereas light kits reflect it. Why wear that in France in that heat!

Other than that we looked well beaten team thought the french looked pretty good and Simon looks to be a handy signing on today's performance

Note to club no more black kits in France!

Very few go to the south of france in the summer and get a result to be fair.

As for NGB4C, If you had a genuine thought go through your head it would set all kinds of speed records. There's a packet of ham with your name on in Tesco. Oh, wait sorry my bad it says 'extra thick CUT'

Not up for it , didn't look interested. Smith a no show, No kicking game, pack beaten, no chance of a result.
Move on and expect a dig in all departments next week.

This forum at times makes me laugh, why give NGBC stick for having an opinion on Owen?. Opinions are like

holes, everyone has one. My thoughts on re signing Owen are simple, he is not the best or Cas would not be getting shut. If there are no better players out there, re sign, if their are get shut.

There was a better player on our books - his name was Peter Fox. But I'd give Tom Johnstone a chance.

We played in black because its our away kit and the white one is too similar to Catalans home kit, and we don't have a third!
Gilmour poor.
we need Walshaw back.
Bad day today all round.
Terrible reffing performance, but we'd have lost anyway.
Rliey tackled in the second half before he was put in touch. Catlans penalty for holding on, after he walked 5m from the play of the ball, tries from forward passes, say no more.
Having said that if they hadn't have knocked on so much, it could have been worse.

But to pick one player out of that performance? Come on!!
For what my opinion is worth, there where others who were equally as poor if not worse but collectively we were just not "at the races" so they all cop it!
In defence of the player (and one I hated the very thought of signing) I think he's done pretty well overall, and to single him out today says everything about the mentality of the poster rather than the attributes of the player.

This.

Why have a go at NGB4C? Because he's an idiot. He only ever comments when any of his scapegoats have had a bad game, never gives them any credit when they've had a good game.
I don't mind people having an opinion but it would be nice to occasionally base it on what actually happens rather than on a preconception of how you think someone will play (just because you don't like them).

I agree peter struggled with the high from time to time, but he did look like he could be bothered! Richard Owen is that laid back he should be vertical on the pitch...

Obviously someone else not in the "clique"

Owen or NGB4C?

No need to be offensive I don't rate Owen I think it's a mistake if we sign him. Stop being a bully and think things through before you speak please

Yeah baby, here begineth and endeth the lesson!!
#practisewhatyoupreach

If by clique you mean the majority of posters on this board who are capable of reasoned debate and offer praise, criticism and thoughts on various players/team matters, at different times - then yes.

Or do you mean the 4-5 posters who say little/nothing when we are winning, then as soon as we lose they magically appear calling for players to be sacked, coaches to be laid off and singling out their scapegoats regardless of whatever form they have been in previously?

I'm a idiot for not rating a half hearted player on a fans forum. Your the idiot. For been on a fans forum With no opinion what so ever.Some may say very dumb.

I deleted the bits that didn't matter.

I vote kinley to be banned for never expressing anything worth a debate just argues with other posters bet you are a 40 year old bloke looking for arguments all the time. PEA SIZED BRAIN WITH NOTHING TO PUT FOR THE LAST 5 YEARS. Yawn yawn

I agree with ngb4c

Owen is a bit of a no no. Does appear to be disinterested when urgency is clearly needed ( we already have Mathers doing that).

They were better...simple as. And Hicks....well !

Commentary team very good. Lots of long pauses and could hear ref. Sick to the back teeth of Stevo and Eddie and their constant talk that drowns out everything - Eddie has even timed it to perfection whenever their is a minutes silence !!

That's the danger in democracy I guess, and I'm 43 actually!!

Hmmm - age request??

Might be a suggestion that ngb4c is going to slowly reveal his true identity. Which way do we take that - is he young and disillusioned with authority... or is he an elder statesman that derides the opinion of those younger than himself.....discuss ! (just jesting)