Is there an echo in here?

I'll keep saying it till he's at Batley

Really ?
You would move our best creative player out of the halves, to accommodate a newbie, who hasn't played for a long time.
Sammut should play where he is most effective and assuming Godinet was only suffering from a bit of cramp, these 2 should be our HB partnership.
Collis has to come in, so we may lose Lyne or, Riley.
For me Riley should miss out as he is a loan player and we want our team to be playing together as long as possible and have a settled team but, with genuine competition for places.

Lynne had a good game today at centre so I'd leave him there. For me it's Sykes out for Collis straight.

Sammut and Godinet look like they could be a great halfback pairing so wouldn't change that up.

Washbrook wasn't needed today. Tautai was immense up the middle so should stay a starting prop for me along with Scruton who drove it in well today.

Probably look at next week..or hope

Mathers
Fox
Collis
Lynne
Riley
Sammut
Godinet
Scruton
McShane
Tautai
Lauititi
Kirmond
Malloy/Ryan

Wildie
Smith
Anderson
Ryan/Malloy

Unfortunately no point throwing Harry in when the halfs played a blinder today.

Thought Mathers did ok out of position for one of the catalan try apart from that miles better than last week.Half back combo of Sammut and Godinet looked good and we looked more fluid without Washbrook in attack but you would think that with him having played 6 in the past both with Hull and us that would not be so.Thought Molloy went well after all his injury problems but lets keep our feet firmly planted Catalan were not the best we will face this season but its a stepping stone to better things of that Im sure.

Sykes to replace Mathers, Collis back into centre in my opinion.

Depends what agreement we made with Warrington, whether the loan of Riley has any kind of playing clause in it.

Not saying this is what I would do, but if I was guessing I could see Sykes dropping out for Collis, Wildie dropping out for Siejka on the bench (not my preference but I can't see us flying someone halfway round the world and then not playing them)

So I would guess

Mathers
Fox
Collis
Lyne
Riley
Sammutt
Godinet
Scruton
McShane
Tautai
Lauitiiti
Kirmond
Washbrook

Siejka
D Smith
Anderson or Raleigh (if back to fitness)
Ryan

I could go with that but, as ever, I wouldn't give Lyne a jersey at any match so, half decent day or not, he can step aside too for me

Sykes has played FB before but how long ago was that? Hes older now and doesnt have the pace he has..

Can he catch or tackle?

I just believe Sykes would offer more in attack especially with his kicking game from fullback, and also defiantly offers more defensively. And I would bet my car he is faster than Mathers.

Fair enough

I've heard that Harry Siejka can play fullback??
Anybody know if this is true?

Ben Jones Bishop can play Full Back

Siejka plays 6. Sammut can play full back

Let's build on the current partnership which has had 2 weeks together and has just helped put 56 past Catalans, not change it.

Idly reading the twitter site of mr Carter last week, he was asked about how the loan deal for Bishop was coming along... His reply was something along the lines:

What deal? You had better ask the press, they seem to know more than I do!

I think he is outstanding at fullback, and Wakefield fans have witnessed him destroy us with long range tries from that position. Can tackle too which helps

Whereas Brian McDermott was directly quoted saying that a few clubs had been in touch re BJB and Wakefield, who were first to inquire, was his likely destination for a loan period.

Agar confirmed on radio leeds that we missed out on BJB.

For now......?

For their experience and quality as proven centres Collis and Sykes for me with Riley also a must on the wing instead of Lyne despite him playing well today.

Why bring Riley in on loan and don't play him? 120 tries in 180 games says it all.

Against London I'd go with...

Mathers
Fox
Collis
Sykes
Riley
Sammut
Godinet
Scruton
McShane
Tautai
Kirmond
Lauitiiti
Molloy

Subs. Ryan, Smith, Raleigh, Wildie

Why change a winning team.
New boys have to play for their place.

Molloy keeps his place especially.

Quote ="PopTart"Why change a winning team. New boys have to play for their place. Molloy keeps his place especially.'" Exactly although Collis coming back is a must plus Raleigh on bench if fit. Scruton had to do overtime today due to lack of props in the 17. Looks like we may have been after winger Ade Gardner aswell? Think with Riley for next month with Fox on wings we've got some pace out wide. www.superleague.co.uk/article/29 ... or-gardner

Quote ="PopTart"Why change a winning team. New boys have to play for their place. Molloy keeps his place especially.'" Exactly although Collis coming back is a must plus Raleigh on bench if fit. Scruton had to do overtime today due to lack of props in the 17. Looks like we may have been after winger Ade Gardner aswell? Think with Riley for next month with Fox on wings we've got some pace out wide. www.superleague.co.uk/article/29 ... or-gardner