Quote ="Upanunder"I don't think we do ourselves any favours by exaggerating events.
I can only comment on what I've seen, and I haven't seen everything but....Peryoux's thing was marginally late, it was a shoulder charge of sorts, more a block, definitely a bit of shoulder but definitely not to the head, couldn't give more than a penalty for that, mebbe a yellow if it was a nailed on try obstruction, but it wasn't, sneyd knew what he was doing and it wasn't going for gold.
Warmsley's was an absolute nothin, but it got 2pts probably by virtue of the Hull squads reaction, I'd be proper happy with that if it was Wakey.
The Turgut thing was, like you say...sh ithouse, I think he got 2 games which in my book is a gdamn gold plate result, because that was filthy.
So Hull win the game, there were no dodgy ref calls, nobody got injured and out for the foreseable, the ban was weak, the squad didn't get carded for overreacting to f all but still every things a bag'o'sh11e, I'm not saying the disciplinary system is any good, it isn't, its crap but you've got bugger all to complain about this week.'"
Walmsley would have been a penalty (Even Powell said so on the SL show) anywhere else on the pitch, the try was scored, he slid in with his knees, he might have tried to pull out, but he didn't need to do what he did.
So you are saying that Sneyd kicked through, so that he could deliberately get hit late (Risking injury) rather that score a try, it was a late shoulder, possibly to the head, it should have been a yellow.
Agree on Turgut, was lucky and he should be happy with that ban.