Tomkins shouldn't have kicked out but he did get a leg in the ribs immediately before it. Like I say it was from both sides but nothing out-and-out dirty, just close to edge aggression from both teams. How I like my rugby personally.

Wigan should have had another try in the first half. The wakey clearly lost the ball before Coley grabbed it. Harsh but didn't matter in the end. I thought Wigan's try was from a forward pass but justice was done for the disallowed try.

Tompkins kick-out wasn't deliberate but Sculthorpe shouldn't have been holding him down. It could have caused an injury but I thought the ref handled it well. I am sure Sam will learn from it.

I think we do need a big unit in our team at times yes, maybe not him though for for such a big lad he is quite quick

How on earth can a Wigan fan possibly complain about holding down Wigan do it week in week out and get away with it. It's the only way thay can give P enough time to get back onside

Of course it was deliberate.

Im yet to see a player whos natural style of getting up is to kick one leg 3 foot in the air.

Tomkins new full well what he was doing.

Being held down gives no player the right to take action like Tomkins did.
The ref is there to hand out punishment for infringes.

Think you should look more closely and you would see that it was Fielden's hand that ripped out the ball for Coley to benefit from.