He was totally out of his depth tonight, he just couldnt keep up at all.

My favourites tonight were the penalty against Carmont when he stole the ball cleanly in a 1on1, the decision that Prescott 'played the ball' with his backside, when turned to face in the other direction on a kick on the 6th, the Hoffman 'knock-on' in the first half, and the complete @rse he made of the whole end of the game - when he just looked like he didn't know what to do.

He's so bad it's not funny - and came close to ruining what was a good game.

The worst bit is that you have no idea what he's going to do. He can penalise for one thing and then completely ignore it for 20 minutes before clamping down on it again. He was bad for both teams.

He was awful tonight. Too many dreadful decisions to name them all. But for a start...

We hand over the ball on leeds 5 yard line after being tackled on the 5th and then he takes our defensive line to the 20. Surely it should only be back 10 yards to the 15?

Pat got impeeded twice whilst running to make a challenge for the high ball one of which we score from (Hoffs try).

Hoffman gets done for playing the ball incorrectly of knock on not sure which after 15 mins or so. This is whilst Lee Smith is perfecting a chicken wing tackle on Hoffs left arm.

Saying all that though the real reason the game was so tight and such a struggle for us was the individual unforced errors from the likes of HH, the Hoff and for once Pat.

Carmont actually did knock on that time.

Yes he did.

Oh, all right then. Haven't watched it back, but generally still poor. It's the fact that he looks like he's making it up as he goes along that worries me - like a dad who's roped into reffing a kids footy match, and keeps getting in situations where he's not sure what to do.

He was just dreadful tonight.

I've just watched it again on sky+

He got most of the decisions right.

Two crucial ones he got wrong, the knock on by Hoffman in the first half, should have been a penalty to Wigan, the Leeds player was all over him at the ptb, and Richards try just after half time, forward by a long way.

But what about the things he missed? Wasn't there a knock on by a Leeds player about 35m out in the 2nd half everybody in the DW except him in saw? I can't remember but I think they went on to score from there. That 's just one example BTW.

you forgot the forward pass and not sending ratboy off for a professional foul.

We got one in the first half Charnley knocked on, but the two I referred to were big decisions particularly Pats try.

There were plenty more than that. The Mcguire knock-on in Finch's tackle, Pat taken out in the air on the first high kick, BJB offside after the ball hits Webb, Joel dragging the ball back and being ruled a knock-on, Sam penalised for not square ahen the Leeds player moves off the mark...

The kick that Sinfield did late on which apparantley Prescott(think it was him) played at?

The numerous occasions Leeds were messing about at the ptb trying to slow it down. They obviously watched John Wells review the Hudds game last week because he said if you dont slow Wigan down they will kill you

Just plain clueless. Poor all round. Gives the impression that he dithers and is undecisive. Should go down a division but he's out token French ref so he won't.

Not blaming him for our poor performance though. Leeds aren't a bad team on paper as they showed last night. If they sack McDermott and get some form together under a new coach they could yet still spring a surprise this season. I had certainly written them off before last night, but they are still capable.

His hand signal was clearly marking FIVE, as in Fifth Tackle. That to me implied he was bringing it back up, to run the firth tackle again, because of some misdermener on the Yorkes part. But then they PTB, and it's game on...

I dont think I saw one Leeds tackle that their guy wasn't swinging around on the ball, not the player, the ball trying to wrench it out (and there were very very few 1on1s from Leeds).

The guy is a joke. It annoys me every time he refs, not just for us, but for anyone, there's people in Aus LAUGHING at us for this guy! Sack that nodder at the top, and get someone in there who knows what they're doing, maybe then the sport can develop.

the BJJ catch when it was in the field of play and he gave a 20 meter restart, a joke.

Don't know about specsavers he needs to go to ref's school

. Started off by nailing both sides for fairly innocuous incidents as though he was laying the law down early and then went on to ignore all the things that mattered. Worst display I have seen from him for both sides. No wonder fans get angry

The Prescott charge down ruling was the most baffling... I mean, the lad's a big unit and if he turns his back on the kicker and it hits him on his arris it's difficult to see how that can be ruled as a charge down.

Terrible ref

He's pants. He would struggle to ref kids his personality is that weak. He gets bullied. On 3 seperate occasions, probably more, he didnt have a clue. The biggest joke is that Stevo thinks he's good.

Prescott wasn't on the field at the time. The Wigan player advanced toward the kicker, that's why the "play on" was given.

What about the first occasion when Richards was taken out (Sinfield?), the Leeds player caught the ball from in play and when he landed one foot was behind the try line the other was in play. Halibut gave a 20 metre restart when it should have been a Wigan penalty, but if not seen then a drop out.
Truly awful decision.

Thankfully we got the result!

He was as bad for both teams though, you can at least give him that.

What about the time where he blew the whistle for a penalty to Leeds, then shouted play on after every single player had stopped? Ridiculous.

I can't even say he was biased , he was e for both teams