6. Edwards
7. Gregory
13. Hanley


I challenge somebody to name a better halves/loose triangle than those three that played together at club level from any era.

Both statements are correct, if by lacking talent you mean that unlike, say Hanley, Edwards wasn't born a great athlete.

Some great players are immensely gifted physically, with the freakish speed of an Offiah, the powerful presence of a Farrell or the hands of a Miles.

Other great players are less gifted physically but have such a ruthless and single minded desire to win and such an appreciation and understanding of the game that they lift themselves from mediocrity to stand alongside the natural born geniuses of the game.

Sean Edwards was such a player. He wasn't born a great player, he made himself a great player. That to me is all the more impressive. His legendary status is fully deserved.

They would give anything to have an Edwards play for them, but then again, to them players like Paul Wellens and Vila Matutia are legends.

One of them thinks the Slug is as good as Jonathan Davies was in his prime.... and no, he wasn't joking.

He's only marginally better than Alan Davies........

the same time i was reading this alan davies was on tv

Daley
Stuart
Clyde

You accepted the challenge but you lost.

Didn't think it was possible to lose an opinion.

I will also add to that list

Lewis
Langer
A.N. Other - it doesn't really matter.


However, I would have thought Miles or Tallis played LF at some point.


The three you have mentioned were great Wigan players, but only Hanley was truely world class.

Edwards was fantastic for Wigan, but only "very good" for GB.

Greg the same and frankly was outclassed by Langer.

Lighten up a little....

Lewis, Langer & Tallis would be outstanding if they had played together at club level.

How about a triangle from Wigan's side c1995-6:

6. Paul
7. Edwards
13. Farrell

That trio would run the other one close!

Thinking about it I'm not sure they did. Tallis would have been a tad too young around 1990 I think.


Miles would have been though. He defo played SR, not sure about LF.

Would have loved to see

6. Barrett
7. Lam
13.Farrell

Mind you we had Johns, Lam and Faz and won nowt



But no I agree, that would have been special.

I think your right, but christ they would have been good together.

Miles was all class, to think, he was another the fans didnt take to at first.

Martyn
Long
Sculthorpe





Shoebottom
Seabourne
Batten

Edwards is a legend just on what he achieved. I do think his ability is massivly overrated, and he never really delivered at the highest level. But at the same time Wigan wouldn't have been the same team without him.

Bless.

I knew id catch one muppett from t'other side of the hill..

Best combinations, not worst. Do keep up.

I hate Saints.

your just very ill informed then?

Nope, you're just unable to notice the