Get rid of either fielden or coley keep one for experience and bring in either Louie McCarthy-Scarsbrook or Luke Burgess both young and we have jeff lima coming that would be nice

Except that LMS isn't anywhere near as good as Coley or Fielden, and Luke Burgess is pants.

Keep both Fielden and Coley, at the right price.

LMS has signed for Saints, Burgess is average at best. Lima is only one year younger than Fielden.

And you think Coley is better than Fielden


[urlhttp://www.superleague.co.uk/statistics_player.php?hs1=2010&hp1=420&hs2=2010&hp2=29&stat=tries&season=2010[/url

Never has been, and never will be.

Was I right about the South Stand?

LMS isnt as good true but at some point we need a long term replacement for coley and fielden id love them both to stay CHEAP but fielden might get better offers from clubs like hull fc but i think coley will stay.

We have long term replacements.

They are called Lee Mossop and Ben Davies, so would you like them to be 2 of our front line props next season?

I hope Stuart takes Wigans offer would be a shame to loose him he has a great attitude to his work and is a good roll model for the younger players

Shame about him signing for saints, Burgess was just a example of a young prop but then again we have o'carrol and prescott

coleys better for the money but next year that should change with fielden coming to the end of his contract yet too see lima played sorry did'nt know his exact age and no yes South stand lol

Good point, yet to see Davies play but Mossop is immense prospect wish we could get james graham he tore morley apart on saturday

Look at this this .. www.superleague.co.uk/statistics ... eason=2010

Look at this this .. www.superleague.co.uk/statistics ... eason=2010

You not watch fridays game?

Quote ="loyal18"Look at this this .. www.superleague.co.uk/statistics ... eason=2010 '" What's that got to do with Fieden and or Coley staying?

Quote ="loyal18"Look at this this .. www.superleague.co.uk/statistics ... eason=2010 '" What's that got to do with Fieden and or Coley staying?

Quote ="loyal18"Look at this this .. www.superleague.co.uk/statistics ... eason=2010 '" Thats show how heavily relied on Graham is

Quote ="loyal18"Look at this this .. www.superleague.co.uk/statistics ... eason=2010 '" Thats show how heavily relied on Graham is

Not sure why he's put that up. Similar tackles, Fielden has missed less, but just doesn't take the ball in as much (but lets be honest, who does).

Can someone who can be bothered work out the metres per carry, looks pretty close to me.

[size=50P.S. in no way am I saying Fielden is as good as Graham, just before the trolls come.[/size

Yeh

Nowt Graham is immence and fielden if good/avrage Graham is on less money i wonder if we offered graham fieldens wage he would come to us

How do you know Fieldens and Grahams salaries?

We paid alot for fielden so his is obv alot and isnt graham a saints homegrown player so im presumeing his wage isnt anywhere near fieldens

So you don't know.


And neither do I

It'll be interesting too see what happens when Graham comes off contract next year, as it will with Eastmond.

Good British players will become "more valuable" as the quota regulations come into play.

In the paper yesterday it stated Pryce was Saints best payed player.

Yes we did pay a lot for Fielden but that does not mean he is on more than Graham.
Yes he is one of our top earners but Graham will be one of Saints top earners to.

I do however think we are moving away from what I.L. said he wanted. I know so far its 3 out 3 in but feel that should be enough imports for this year i want to see the day we field 13 British players and just 4 overseas players in our team every week. That should be part of the Wigan way.

I thought what he said was Wigan lads with the odd world class talent in there?

At the same time though, I can see what you mean, but I also don't think that there is a prop ready to step up on a consistent basis (although Davies isn't far away), a HB partner for sam (or FB) anytime soon.

However I still maintain that we have only gone for Hoffman because he's available, and he's a talent we couldn't miss out on.

I know this is a bit O/T here but i have this funny gut feeling that next year with 3 of MM old clubs players coming in it might have an unsettling effect on the team as a whole. I do hope i am wrong but we will have to see i would not feel the same if it was 3 players from different clubs but 3 from the same could end up with a little favoritism towards them which has not been shown this year.

AG you may be right but I doubt it.

We have brought in three players who Madge knows well. The systems we are using are those used by Melbourne, so I'm expecting the players to settle into the playing patters relatively quickly.

We haven't been afraid to drop players who have under performed this season, I expect the same thing to apply next.

what about wood from warrington

Too old.