Think about it, they are played for completely different reasons.

Also due to the SC changes how strong will an Exiles squad be in three or five years time? Imports are going to dwindle both in numbers and quality thats a pretty much given so how will the concept grow?

I like the idea for the end of the season as a friendly for a FULL England team, but making it out to be our version of Origin is just ridiculous.

I should think the way the game is going in Britain, there soon won't be enough decent 'exiles' to make up a team.

Maybe then we can have a good standard of 'War of the Roses'.

War of the Roses style would admittedly be closer to the Origin idea.

I dont see it happening though. I would hope that in a few years France and Wales will have improved to the point they provide more than an adequate test for England so that when the Exiles doesnt work we can do that instead.

I would much prefer Lancs v Yorks but they need to come out with eligibility rules to start and then state that if players don't play then they don't get picked for England otherwise we end up with 2 reserve sides. Lancs would have a decentish side

Tomkins
Charnley
Goulding
Ratchford
Riley
Sinfield
Myler
Morley
Roby
Hill
Farrell
Hock
O'Loughlin

I'm sure I missed a few out but not a bad 13 imo.

I know he was born in Oldham but it would seem so strange Kevin representing Lancashire as he's with synonymous with Leeds.

maybe a qualification rule could be "number of seasons played east or west of pennines?"

It should be based on origin, so that the current strong sides don't dominate it. This was a problem they had in Aus with the early days of origin when it was based on where you currently played, and since Sydney has a lot of teams and Queensland had very few, NSW were dominant. They changed it to "Origin" and it took off from there, really.

Isn't it based on where you first played first grade RL?

As much as Sinfield is a Leeds legend I'm sure he'd want to represent Lancashire. It would be crazy if he didn't.

If the Australian rugby league had anything about it, and wanted the world game to grow they'd release the English lads for any origin match. That would add huge interest to the games but they couldn't give a dam.

Example of 2 sides including those lads-

Lancs-

Tomkins, Charnley, Watkins, Ratchford, Riley, Sinfield, Myler, Graham, Roby, Mossop, Farrell, Hock, O'Loughlin.

Subs- Hill, Morley, Currie, Lomax.

Yorks- Hardaker, Briscoe, Cudjoe, Reed, Hall, Widdop, Chase, Crabtree, McIlorum, S Burgess, Ellis, Westwood, JJB.

Subs- G Burgess, Bailey, Ferres, Burrow.

Two very good sides there.

Thankful that we scraped home last night. Our points difference is so huge now that a 1pt victory with a very inexperienced side is probably more valuable than an 80 point thumping like was given to HKR.

Now, here's hoping that our injured first teamers are sufficiently recovered in time for the Wire game - and not a moment sooner.

I'd be more than happy to see no Wigan players involved next weekend.