im not complaining i had £20 double widness/swansea. get in there, perching,

I respect Wane but I'm not respecting his decisions at the moment, to call for his resignation is stupid but I hope he learns from this and moves on! With Maguire in charge we would be top of the league and a good points difference, Wane should have picked up on the fact our strongest side available must be played!

For me this was strike 2. But yes, there is 1 wigan fan calling for the sack.

Well it seems Waney got something right! www.loverugbyleague.com/news_836 ... -soon.html

Well it seems Waney got something right! www.loverugbyleague.com/news_836 ... -soon.html

Bit of a mixed bag day St Pats U7's win at Orrell due to "hard work and determination" and the Warriors lose away at Widnes due to "management stupidity" - it would have been nice to have a double win but hey ho it's one of those days I guess, deserved results in both cases

I haven't read the above, but here's hoping that there's over 50 people who've previously called the OP an idiot.

Too right, I presume O'Brien had a good game then?

I haven't, Guerrier. Even if you don't agree, people are entitled to their opinion........overreaction by the OP, though.

Rank stupidity on Wane's part.

Madge was guilty of not blooding youngsters last year but there was never a need to take out four of your best players to do so.

The young players will not have learned a thing. Far better to blood one or an absolute max of two in a game alongside the experienced players who can help them along. Not chuck them all in at once. We are already having to play Hughes as George is out so there is inexperience there already.

It's London next and he could have given different youngsters a game next week so absolutely no need to do what he did today.

Now he will have to play his best side so as not to lose more league points.

I'd love to hear his excuses for this one.

The travelling fans have been ripped off by Wane doing something I would only expect of Millward.

What does an inept Wigan performance have to do with Leeds!! You may think your the worlds best club but Leeds are officially the worlds best club!!

Didnt Widnes have more first team players missing?

There was nothing wrong with the team selection when we were 18 points up. Somebody has to give Widnes some credit for hanging in and sneaking the win.

Why did Finch try to offload on the 1st tackle with a minute to go 10 yards from the Widnes line? He was captain and one of the more experienced players.

Poor decision from him, as was Charnleys kick straight into touch after ta Widnes try.
Those along with a few stupid penalties conceded were not the coaches fault.

If there are any referees on here, what is the ruling regarding stopping the game after a head injury? It certainly cost Wigan when Goulding was down for about five tackles.

you could understand resting players towards the end of the season, but after 1 month do they honestly need a rest.

well done widnes, wane got what he deserved, disrespect for widnes and also the wigan fans.

No no no the word you are looking for my dear friend is TEAM!!!!!

Didn't Saints do something similar a few years back when they deliberately fielded an understrength team

Resting players en-mass in this game will have no effect on their fitness toward the end of the season. It would have been an easy game for them to play in and hardly up there with a game v Wire.

The youngsters won't have benefited either. Young players benefit by being introduced one at a time into an experienced team playing alongside the established players not being chucked in all together and then going on to lose a game.

Clubs are still supposed to play their best sides (though the rule is slightly different than it used to be) and there are good reasons reason for that one of which includes not ripping off the fans by putting weakened sides out. If Wane has the RFL to answer to he ought not to be surprised.

Wane got the job with a lot of goodwill from many fans myself included but if he carries on making stupid mistakes like this he will use it up very quickly.

meaningless game, they all are until the season starts in August

There is only one reason we lost and that was Wane's stupidity.

There isn't a game Wigan play were mistakes are not made so highlighting those above is irrelevant.

Also saying there was nothing wrong with that selection when we were 18 points up is completely daft. It's the final result that counts not how we were going at some arbitrary point in the game. How many league points did being 18 in front get us in the end?

We lost the game because Wane put an inexperienced side out and we both know it.

What an absolute joke of a thread.
That's the most reaction i am giving it

From what I could see he deliberately threw the ball away to try to win the penalty. He realised Widnes hands were on the ball so just flicked it forwards to make it look like it was ripped out. It was just daft.

He made two great individual breaks but on the whole I was disappointed with Finch. His passing was a bit wayward and his kicking was very poor, and I can't honestly say he showed much leadership or encouragement. McIlorum and Goulding seemed to be the only players trying to show some enthusiasm.

Also disappointed with him storming off down the tunnel too. It's a bit pathetic.

However, I'm not one for personal abuse on forums but anyone who actually thinks Shaun Wane should be sacked is an absolute moron and should not be allowed to watch rugby league again until they get their head tested. What a joke of a thread.

After today SW would get nailed for me. Live by the sword, did by it.

If you are serious then I bet you are looking at a healthy sum for that? do share.....and infact I very nearly put the same on myself, but in seperate bets!

Ey well, at least they'll all be in the pub tonight for a good p*ss up until the early hours of the morning celebrating today's result......oh wait

You either have the Sports Almanac from BTTF or you have money to burn.

After the emotion of today has subsided I'll agree with this, until then I'm going to remain bitterly disappointed and let down by Shaun Wane. After all the growling and tubthumping about showing no mercy and doing things the Wigan Way that got the fans enthused and fully behind him he then goes completely against that phiolosophy by totally disrespecting the opposition and doing Denis Betts job of motivating the Widnes side. Today was an opportunity for a merciless 80 minute performance against a side that are probably the worst in the competition.

That said the title of this thread is just bloomin daft. I'd be happy with an admission from SW that he got it wrong and he's learnt his lesson.