If the tackle had been reversed, Carvell had been knocked out due to a high tackle, but was dipping into the tackle, would you class it as a penalty? For me you are responsible for where your limbs are, if you smash someone in the face...whether they're dipping or not, you deserve to face the consequences.

no I wouldnt as he would be dipping into the tackle.

So if Carvell is lying unconcious on the floor, possible broken jaw, you wouldn't want any type of punishment for the offending player?

can you imagine the uproar from Wire fans if Coley did exactly the same thing as Carvell to Harrisson this week and Fielden does exactly what Morley did to Myler? I'll take you back to the time Mathers made that high tackle on King...this board nearly went into meltdown because of the crying from the idiots. Double standards.

if he ducks into the challenge thats his problem as his running style is wrong, as for Carvell, i couldnt care less about his jaw.

It was a bad one that but was instinct more than anything.

You're allowed to hand people off, not use the forearm or elbow. No such thing as a lead arm. If he had his arm out straight as you're supposed to and he caught the elbow then fair enough it's an accident, when you go in like he did with the arm bent and elbow / forearm leading then it's deliberate.

Secondly, you go into a tackle with the shoulder, to go in without your head going in with it is a tad hard unless you're an emu.

Arm had to be bent as he was carrying the ball with it, and as to being no such thing as a lead arm ...oh dear

I worded wrong, my aruement was how you go in with the arm.

ah ok. For me he went in leading with the ball carrying arm. IF jackson had of beens tood up straight he woudlnt have been hit high he wold have been hid in the mid rift.

That's basically all i'm saying. Pedro is only saying this because it's carvell. If it was a wigan player he'd be screaming blue murder. At least if it was a wigan player i'd call it as I see it.

I dont understand what you mean there Jeff...why would I be screaming blue murder for again?

pedro17 is a Wigan fan aint he?..

Fail on my part lol *blush* Sorry Pedro! You were wticking up for a Wire player so I naturally figured...

All charges now posted on here.
[urlhttp://www.therfl.co.uk/about/disciplinary.php?&startrow=0[/url

We should hear later this afternoon.

Would love them both to be banned, but im not getting my hopes up.

Besides, if we beat them with both playing and no Phelps, Eddie will probably have a stroke.

and clarke will have many fast vigorous strokes!!!

Think Morley will get a 1 match as he could have pulled out and he did hit Sherwin from behind. But Carvell's was much worse than the one Mather's did when he was at Wigan think he will get 2 matches as its a 2 to 3 match offense.

The difference is that Clarkey is pro-Wigan. Eddie is pro-anyone who's playing Wigan.

Moz got off with it.

Carvell got 1 match.

Cooper will come in to replace Carvell.

EDIT. Sorry, didn't see the new thread.

[url=http://viewtopic.php?f=28&t=445264=#FF0000viewtopic.php?f=28&t=445264[/url