much like my reaction when i read that

I suppose with all the crap they are getting, we can excuse a little giddiness from the less mature...

My thoughts exactly.

I was sat in middle of bulls fans and considering you was all screaming that charnley was in touch even tho he threw the ball back in play and never even touch the white line him self , I'll take the rest of your comments like a pinch of salt

Oh and singing top of the league your having a laugh was comical haha

The ref was shocking and Bradford did nothing but spoil and slow the game down and they got away with it. Consistently holding down, messing about, offside. Yeh, they where more spirited but that still doesn't excuse the fact that they got away with murder. the only positive for us is that had it not been for that total brain fart from Micky MC our youngsters atleast gave them a game and would have probably won even if we played poorly. I think Fuzzy going off made a big difference to, Jack Hughes just couldn't cope in defence. I had a feeling we could end up losing this match but it's obvious that wane is wiling to take the risk, and lets face it we can afford to , for the sake of keeping our players as fresh as possible.

Nope. Don't suppose you saw Finch 5m offside when Wigan were on their tryline.

Good to know we can still bribe these ref's....

I was at the Stone Roses gig last night so haven't seen the incident. I suppose the main question I have is what's the chances of him being banned for the semi?

If he is banned the game becomes a real struggle IMO.

Mickey Mac hasn't been up before the disciplinary for about two years so I would imagine a one match ban will be coming his way.

ref held up a yellow....how did it suddenly become red?

1 game ban no more IMO. But anyone else thinks i'm a child or taking the pi$$ for that opinion feel free to say



On another note, congratulations on a great crowd last night. The Wigan marketing team do a great job, maybe the RFL should hire them!

Grade B 1-2 matches - take the early guilty plea, miss Wakey, rested and fresh for the semi final - jobs a good'un.

He held up a red.

I was in the south stand, it WAS a RED!

I can imagine the flloodlights may have made the card look bright and therefore yellow. The floodlights are on the west and east stands so I am not surprised thats what you saw.

ok....that explains why most of the crowd thought it was yellow

Would the mass hallucination of Wiganers seeing yellow rather than red, also be a good indicator that maybe Bull Mania has some decent points about the ref. With so many Wiganers suffering from the effects, it may explain why they missed some of the other points from Bull Mania.

Surely your taking the shooter,Charnley was so far over the white line he nearly knocked my pint out of my hand.Did you not see him laughing his head off at Karl Pryce when it happened and then two tackles later you scored.

I think most fans saw a yellow because that's what they were (rightly) expecting to see. It's rugby, not football.

Hell with how long the ref took to make a decision I thought McIlorum was going to be let off scott free.

Just seen the replay - Elima should get a couple of games for that elbow. Obviously he won't because the RFL are inept.

Yep, and should be "sending off sufficient", but MM will probably get a game or two.

Where was the replay?

On SLTV

How many games off did the players at MM get who threw punches?

Tuson got 1 match, Hock got 2.

If Tuson got 1 match for throwing about 15 punches, MM should get NFA.