the only thing is us salford fans were walking back just singing and having a joke and none of yous were smiling please can you smile for once

jog on

hehehe got it in 1

I thought Richards' 2nd try came from a knock on, other than that I can't really complain too much - we were beaten convincingly, just disappointed we didn't make more of a game of it.

Well played Wigan

Nice to here, unlike them St helleners at Murrayfield

just got in but my first rection to your post is

what a bitter manc , ref gave us nothing all match and kept you in it!

are you havin a laff

When will you lot get it in to your thick skulls, we are from Salford which is a City in its own right.
Manchester is next door to Salford.
Salfordians live in Salford
Mancunians live in Manchester


As for the Ref he was poor for both teams.
The best team won, and it was a shame we could not give you a better game.

I agree they out played us but those were bad decisions

Thats what your fans was doing before the end of the game. Why would a load of your fans be leaving before the end when your winning ?

To get off the car park?

There not allowed on Tomkins though, or the Wigan fans might cry

Still your winning the game. They could of stayed to the end and clapped your players

I hope to God we get Gateshead in next round

I'd settle for Gateshead being IN the next round

Most did. Why peddle lies to those who know what really happened?

What ?

It's just been on the news that the RL have watched a tape of the game and they fully agree with you, they have corrected the score and you win the match and go through to the semi final.

But are they doing anything about the "No Try" by HKR After the Hooter went for HT????

Thought Not!

Alibert had a shocker last night for both sides!

Again I think we finished on the wrong end of a Penalty Count!

There was a set of 6 late in the 1st half were on 3 x seperate PTB there were 6 or 7 Salford players 3/4 yards in front of the ref and nothing!

At that point I commented that it was all on and just get away with whatever you can as the ref isnt going to each PTB the same.

Rates of our team today-

Phelps 7-linked up ok and tackled well, returned the ball with some pace to get us better field position.
Roberts-5 Didn't do anything. Returned the ball at walking pace. Does he do enough to keep the leagues top try scorer out of the team? No.
Gleeson- 6 Fell sorry for the guy, never is put through a gap by poor halfbacks
Caromont- 7 Worked hard, few half breaks
Richards- 8, kicked well and finished off his chances, good wing play.
Tomkins-7. only for the second half, first half he did nothing.
Tommy 6-If there's no creativity you look to your HB, and once again, despite a purple patch, we looked lost and flat in attack.
Coley 7-Put some good drives and tackles in
Riddlell-4 Offered next to nothing
Prescott-4 trots upto the line, then does nothing.
Hock 9-Outstanding, Made his own work looking a constant threat
Bailey-A spent force
Lockers-8 Solid in defense linked up well in attack. well played.
---------
Feka 8-Awesome in attack as always
McC 8/9-Quality. Puts Riddell to shame. Looked lively and effected, the team looked so much better with him on the field.
Hansen 6-Did nothing, but was playing out of position, usually his does nothing in the SR
Tomkins 6-worryingly quiiet in attack compared to this stage last season.

All good reasons to ignore any of your Tactical Genius comments in future.

Explain?

Because posts like this on other threads when talking about the Wigan team for next year

Last son of Wigan Wrote

"It's not bad.

Just prefer not to have Riddell and Hansen in it."

Prove that you have no intention of being fair in your assessment of players, just promoting the players that you believe should be in the team rather than how they actually perform.

Roberts had a Good Game.
Riddell had a Good game.
Hansen had a Good game.
Bailey had a decent game and we defend a Whole lot better when he's on
Precott had a Good game.

McCollorum had a Good Game but to give 8/9 out of 10 whilst Riddell a 4 and then back that up with your comments show you have no intention of being fair.

As for Roberts, still a far better all round Winger than Ainscough as the week before proved against Wire.