Your point is?

One was 1/2 - 1 second late, one was 3 - 4 seconds late with a elbow as well, that clear it up?

if your big men go throwing the weight around at our little men then the same thing happens back its only fair is nt it oh but were every tony smith works newt get s pulled up for his men

nathan browns favourite quotes eye for an eye

Wire fans making out as though he went in 5 minutes later and elbowed him in the face knocking him out or something. He landed a couple of seconds late at the most and it can't have been that bad as Myler got up straight away and didn't seem bothered by it.
It was clearly stupid by Tomkins but it doesn't deserve a ban.

Little men ?

These are all pro rugby players, they're all tough buggers, Myler's a midget in rugby terms but i wouldn't call him soft to face

Reluctantly must agree with this post.

The one on Tomkins is debateable but the one on TL was far worse, can't remember who it was but the replay showed a clear movement towards TL AFTER the ball was passed. Wasn't high but he should be up too.

Mr Squeeky clean Tomkins has had more penalties given against him than any other player this season.

Yes, but Joel Tomkins' elbow was directly to the face, maliscious and full of intent. Oh and very dangerous. Those late tackles off the ball were rather lazy, mistimed etc, but penalty was sufficient.

Anyway, these 'hits' you elude to are hardly a comparison with Tomkin's elbow shot. Should you actually attempt to use a little unbias perspective that is!

True but that doesn't make him a dirty player and neither will it have any effect on how he's treated at Red Hall.

Most of Joel's penalties this year have been given for holding down in the tackle, not for anything malicious such as high tackles.

I watch Joel week in week out and I stand by my statement that he's not a dirty player.

Absolutely how it looks to me on the replay too. It's a cheap shot, no doubt, but Wire fans screaming that he basically dropped onto his head with an elbow are well wide of the mark unless I've been missing something when watching it.

i think you must have missed the bit where he landed on his head with his elbow.

I'm sure it was his upper chest rather than his face. I mean, a 2nd rower dropping his elbow on your face would cause much more damage.

That'll be why myler got up and looking around for the bus that just hit him.

Tomkins stole Randy Savage's finishing move.

Joel and Waney are more than welcome to pop round for a brew while they're waiting.

TBH given the number we seem to have to make the trip over to Leeds on a Tuesday night, I should set up a caff - I'd make a killing.

No Morley then for the very late cowardly hits on Tomkins a Tommy after they'd kicked? What a surprise.

they weren't late, thats why.


Some of you are just winding yourselves up about it now.

Calm down, have a coke and a smile.

That made me laugh. Yeah, Carvell could have hurt himself if he hadn't raised his forearm...it was self defence!

They were late, only slightly but my concern was that both tomes Morley led with his feet, which was dangerous.

I wasn't calling for a ban but surely a warning should have been admonished.

I wonder if Danny Tickle will get the same ban that Jack Hughes got when playing for Wigan u20's.

Why? It was a derby, there was a fight. Big deal. £300 fine and a slap on the wrist.
Now, Tomkins on Myler was late and full of intent should be at least 4 games IMO. I can't stand Myler but Joel was out of order.

If that was your little Sammy you lot would want blood one eyed some of you.

Ball is well down before Tomkins decides to lead with the elbow to the head of Myler.

Funnily enough Myler didn't seem d.
I don't see the point in either sets of fans arguing over this it wasn't as bad as people make out, nor was it totally acceptable

Well considering that Tickle's offence has been classed as a Grade B offence I doubt it. Was Hughes scrapping with Wire that much worse Rogues?