To be fair on Kimmorley he was out for 6 weeks prior to the finals and was playing with a plate in his face.

Indris was poor. His defending is very poor. No Karl Pyrce though. Indris at least puts the effort in.

Yeah they mentioned that in commentary. Glad to he Kimmorley doing it in a good team. He was wasted at Cronulla.

I'd love to see Slater in a Wigan shirt. Class player.

Two words Nathan Hindmarsh. The guy does about 50 tackles a game. Seems like a right character as well, used to laugh when they had him on the Footy show.

And he's still not found a pair of shorts in his career that fits his Ar*e



Class player but sick of him mooning.

Hindmarsh to similar to hansen to choose him over so many others.

Slater would be my pick, still the best and has so much influence over a game.

Cam Phelps by far...

I thought that when I watched Dogs and Parra. Everyone was ranting and raving about him, but I dont rate him at all. Played at centre and did nothing except miss tackles and was easily brought down in attack. I said the same about Pryce as well at the time

I tell you who i would have in a flash. Jeff Lima!. Ths guy is a bruiser and a half.

The only way I could agree that Slater is reliable is if we were talking about effort. He will always, always put in. He makes a lot of errors and that makes him unreliable. "That pass" in the World Cup Final was not out of character, let me tell you. That said, his confidence to try those things is also what makes him a great player.

Jarryd Hayne is the best fullback (and player) of 2009.

Hayne over slater imo. Hayne has been out of this world this season.

Puts it into perspective though doesnt it. What do we have to argue about? Richard Owen vs Shaun Briscoe lol