Do not think he got a chance to show his ability in the short time he was as Wire.

True, depends whether you assume each player is at his peak or just the peak of his time in SL

I can't believe Harris even at his best has been mentioned above Trent Barratt? i'd even go with Henry Paul above Harris. All about personal choice I suppose.

Radlinski
Robinson
Lyon
Newlove
Vainikolo
H Paul
Long
Fielden(pre form dip)
Cunningham
Peacock
Farrell
Morley
Sculthorpe

subs
Anderson
Vagana
Ellis
R Paul(in his pomp)

At their peak I'd put both Paul and Harris above Barrett.

You must be joking. Barrett was the best 6 in SL since Kenny.

Dave

In your opinion.

He was invisible against Saints in several humpings, which is probably why I don't rate him as highly as those two.

Correct. If we're assuming everyone is at their peak then Johns, Furner, Pongia, Renouf, Clyde, Mullens etc should be in most peoples teams.

I would have thought their form in SL would be the clincher, neither Clyde nor Mullins did diddly squat during their time with Leeds.

Though Clyde did inspire one of the better crowd songs.

Surprised no-ones mentioned Darren Albert.

He was playing in a poor Wigan team compared to alot of the world class players Wigan have had down the years. Even a 6 of his or even Lockyers quality cannot play behind a beaten pack.

radlinski
robinson
newlove
connolly
vanikolo
barrett
long
fielden
kfc
peacock
furner
faz
sculthorpe

Surely Senior would be ahead of Connolly in a "Superleague" 13?

Not a bad side other than that - I'd have Joynt over Furner (but that may be the Saints specs talking) and Paul/Harris over Barrett.

1. Wellens
2. Robinson
3. Lyon
4. Newlove
5. Vainikolo
6. Martyn
7. Long
8. Fielden
9. Cunningham
10. Fairleigh (astonished so few have included him!)
11. Peacock
12. Farrell
13. Sculthorpe

14. Graham
15. Roby
16. Furner
17. Morley

My memory is farked so apologies to the great players I may have missed out. I picked Roby over Lowes purely because of modern tactics which demand two hookers in the team. I doubt Lowes could function as an 'impact' hooker.

Radz
Robinson Connelly Lyon Lesbian
Barrett Long
Fielden Richie Morley
Peacock Scully
Faz
-----------

And never showed up against Warrington, so, I am afraid he defiantely doesnt get my vote! And even the Wigan fans must remeber how poor he was in the last season! Harris for me...proved his worth over and over again.

Harris
Robinson
Lyon
Senior
Vianakolo
Henry Paul
Long
Morley
Lowes
Fairleigh
Peacock
Farrell
Sculthorpe

Cunningham
O'Connor
Vagana
Furner

Lowes over Cunningham is just hilarious. Christ someone has even included Darren Fleary!

Vagana

It took everything in me not to pick Tommy Martyn at 6. He will be one who alot of people wouldnt have thought about. As much as i hate to say it, he was a great player for saints at the beginning of super league

Ill admit to ROFLing at that one

At his best Paul perhaps edges Tommy out (although sans two knee reconstructions I don't think anyone in SL could live with him) but I don't think Paul and Long could play well together.

Quote ="Scotty Keeeeeeench"It took everything in me not to pick Tommy Martyn at 6. He will be one who alot of people wouldnt have thought about. As much as i hate to say it, he was a great player for saints at the beginning of super league'" www.youtube.com/watch?v=RUH4vt1978Y One of the best tries in super league.

Quote ="Scotty Keeeeeeench"It took everything in me not to pick Tommy Martyn at 6. He will be one who alot of people wouldnt have thought about. As much as i hate to say it, he was a great player for saints at the beginning of super league'" www.youtube.com/watch?v=RUH4vt1978Y One of the best tries in super league.

Alternatively, watch this. [url=http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cSaonHNsZ08&feature=PlayList&p=81C1419900AE31E6&playnext=1&playnext_from=PL&index=3One of the best fights in Super League[/url Got that sent to me by a mate the other day.

Senior,lyon,newlove,robinson,lam?