Fully agree, he's shown some promise in low intensity matches but also showed he was an accident waiting to happen.

A punishing pre season and some pre season action will give us a pretty handy player IMO.

zzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzz

Here she is, right on cue.

You've not got a clue.

I agree, very impressed with him tonight.

Oh I do apologise. I didn't realise I wasn't entitled to an opinion. Why choose childish remarks all because I say something you disagree with?

His distribution was poor, he missed tackled and gave penalties away. Funnily enough, 2 of my Wigan-supporting friends have txted me saying something similar. I knew I didn't imagine it.

did you miss the good distribution from the floor giving the outside backs time on the ball or the huge physical presence he gives us? but he does need to work on scooting he doesn't go it enough some times.

There's no questioning his physical presence. He's a very aggressive player and gets his forwards going.

However tonight, in my opinion and others I've spoken to, he did more bad than good. As for him being MOM, that's a joke pick.

As I said earlier, Flower and Mossop were excellent, also Smith kicked well and Green's try was very good.

Interesting that you and your 2 imaginary fans think he was poor yet he is getting message after message on Twitter off other players from other sides congratulating him on a great performance

Constant trolling is childish, boring and sad.

That shall be my final response to you as its not worth it.

Opinion that isn't the same as yours = trolling?

Your mind works in strange ways.

Yes it's very interesting that not everyone agrees. How amazing.

Can someone not ban the yellow giraffe or how do I mute him? He is de railing almost every thread and it's getting tedious, no doubt he will disappear once saints get knocked out of the play offs.

Ban me for what? Saying McIlorum didn't play well?

Be honest, if a Wigan fan said the same as I did, would it get this reaction?

I can't believe it's got to the point where you lot are calling for me to be banned for literally just giving an opinion. Some of you need to realise that this board is open to fans of all clubs and people are entitled to give opinions.

Stop crying just because I don't agree with you all.

Mcilorum wont get away with kicking the ball away constantly like he did tonight under a different ref though i wouldn't have thought.

well done on the win, your coach got the tactics spot on tonight.

click on his profile...then select "make foe"...his posts will be invisible to you

are you being serious? did it have an effect on the game? i didn't notice him doing it once.

Who knows, he wasn't the only one either - it looked like it was a tactic at times, to try and slow down the game/our attack. Very unsportmanlike even if it didn't affect the game.

Both sides did it when they were forced to drop out. Wouldn't say one was worse than the other

It made me chuckle when your fans booed Bentham off at half time.

He only reffed one side in the first half and it wasn't Huddersfield.

its probably a good job he did, if he did because your team looked like they was blowing at the 60th minute mark. the only team struggling for intensity tonight was huddersfield and our forwards on top which generally means we win the ruck.

True - their forwards looked gone on the hour (apart from Ferres who looked a threat all night).

No love in - he has been poor by his standards since his op but not tonite,

His distribution was good but his allround defence was excellent.

Green MoM by a all smmargin, Flower was awesome agreed as they say its forwards that win matches, backs decide by how many

i'm not on about drop outs, hand overs, penalties, at scrums etc.

ref probably missed is as Brough was in his ear all game

I was ridiculed for suggesting we play 3 props and a 2nd rower on the bench with Micky mac playing the full 80. I hope we stick with this for the rest of the playoffs.