Only plus point for Saints that though i've been impressed with K P P when i've seen him

KPP and Isa really are way out of their depth. There’s no way Newcastle will play him in the centre surely?! He’s miles off being a capable player in that position.

Outstanding in defence, outstanding in attack. Way, way too many errors from both centres though and highlights the need for specialist positional players. I'm not going to knock anyone though. We were much, much the better side. O'Neil has to be in the squad going forward. He is dynamic and offers something different.

Thank you St Helens for having your worst match ever (again) and us having our best............... Oh no... It's all the ref's fault, Iv'e just read pages of it. Want a laugh? You know where to go

Anyone seen that Warrington wolves chap?

Saw him in town earlier buying a new pencil case.

Lots to think about with that one. Great effort with tryline defence and again we show the ability to be ruthless with any half chance. Mike Cooper was really strong for us.

Those handling errors need to be cut right down though. When Saints get some 3/4 players back we won't get away with that, particularly as they are clearly better at winning territory.

I thought selecting Isa at left centre and KPP on the right was bizarre. Cade Cust looked well off the pace at times. Farrell's injury could be a massive blow.

Great effort from the Wigan club generally to progress as far as they have in a year.

Hope to god Faz is ok. Doesn't look good though.

Welsby world class?

PAH!!!!!!

Saints had their entire first team out injured, that's why they lost....

oh, and the ref

2-3 pens on our line and could even get over pathetic

Best team on the night won. Terrific goal line defence by Wigan and some poor defence from Saints.

It looked like Saints were trying to get all the errors out of their system in one go. Wigan are unlikely to get as much free ball again.

Smithies is a nasty piece of work. Gamesmanship from him going to ground while playing the ball without a hand on him to win the penalty. (Actually it didn’t think it was all that bad but worth making the point after all the silly comments about Myler earlier in the week.)

Cust was lucky to stay on the pitch. He clearly put his hand between Simm’s legs and lifted. Be interesting to see if the Disciplinary Panel show an interest.

Learned from the best, Mr Walmsley.

Don't recall Cust doing a Makinson?

Bench pressing somebody by bowling ball gripping the balloon knot... Might give that a go in the gym on Monday.

We heard that after the CC semi. We also heard Saints couldn't play that bad again and we couldn't play as good. Maybe Saints just aren't that good, just a thought.

Always good Vs Saints (especially if you went to Magic) & even better to beat them at home. It's certainly been a while (2019??) Since I've said that.

2017 I think. 5 years.

We made just as many unforced errors as them, some pretty dumb ones at times. The difference was we were good enough to play some rugby and take our chances and all they wanted to do was try and barge over.

Both teams have players, and influential ones at that to come back in.

If we ever manage to cut out these silly errors we will do something special.

Wow.

I know the pandemic puts a couple of years, but that is a long time ain't it.

Mike Cooper had a blinding game for us. All though we made struggled for meters I think all the forwards had a good game

Thought Faz, Cooper, Bateman, Smith, Smithies, French and Field were outstanding tonight.

Not taking anything away from anyone in the team though who were all superb in key effort areas.

Something very special happening at this club and Matty Peet is at the core of it.

Couldn't agree more re Peet, clearly a happy group. Thought Marshall deserved plaudits as well.

I thought Marshall came up with a few dumb plays that put us under pressure at times hence not mentioning him.

His effort is outstanding but I sometimes question his thought process.

Can’t deny though he came up with some key plays at significant times during the game.

We’re 2 from 4 against them and we can be pretty happy with that. We’re surely due a game against them were we stop making silly errors with the ball. We’ve given them a leg up in each game but luckily enough tonight they matched us. Outside of those errors we were very good and there were one really impressive performances. The centre position is a huge worry and one Peet needs to give serious thought to.

One last point to warm the cockles before bed was the sight of Welsby being harassed throughout the game and coming up with a string of errors. The Wigan players looked like they hadn’t forget his antics at Magic and seemed determined to get in to him.

Refs fault? He absolutely blitzed us for ten minutes that 2nd half.