AS A SALFORD FAN DO U WANT HIM BACK. CANT DEFEND FOR TOFFEE

Give him a chance.

Had a shocker apparently. But Salford did play him on the wing.

centre/wing/fullback u still have to be able to tackle 4 tries down his wing.he is only here for 1 month so how much of a chance can he have.

His defence was questionable for Wigan in two early season run outs in fairness. Will have a watch when it's shown by Sky later.

Of course. I will have to see the highlights for myself.

Never rated him in all honesty. His defence is too weak to be a centre and he very rarely passes to his winger (see Mark Calderwood)

Gleeson/Carmont or Gleeson/Pryce will do me for the next few years thanks

Hardly shocking news.

Yeah I'd rather have kept Liam Colbon.

Never rated him either

No but between the two. I thought Colbon proved a usual squad player. Certainly could score tries.

Isn't Goulding's record better than Colbon's was?

I suppose Colbon could play SR every now and then.

One of our main problems at the moment is that we have too many players who are simply 'average'. I would imagine down to bad management with the cap (barrett, fielden, vaealiki, moran etc etc)

Barrett.

I'm guessing that he means the amount we paid him, not that he's average.

Goulding 20 tries in 56 matches.
Colbon 18 tries in 53 matches.

Not much in it. Although Goulding played a lot more off the bench - so maybe I talk a load of sh*te?

Exactly. We paid him a fortune meaning we could only afford 'average' players to play alongside him

im more interested as to why you have a user name like that and support Salford.......They hardly have a Weaste hardcore following do they?

i actually come from wigan and have supported both teams for 15 years

I wonder who the first winger we had that popped into the second row was? I could just see Ferguson or Offiah packing down! I remember Richard Russell playing hooker as well as wing.

So we should have kept him just for that

Billy B????
Tony Iro????

Not at all, a winger is a winger, a second row a second row. IIRC Goodway spent a b it of time on the wing when we were with injuries,

He'd never be
Big enough
Fast enough
Strong enough

for todays Superleague.

but hed still stand out above every other player in superleague by a mile!

I doubt goulding stands a chance,

weve got gleeson and carmont- and we seem to be fast tracking thornley and i wouldnt be surprised to see him when carmont retires, i also wouldnt be surprised to see karl pryce in the other centre in years to come.