[urlhttp://www.sportinglife.com/rugbyleague/news/story_get.cgi?STORY_NAME=rleague/10/02/15/RUGBYL_Disciplinary.html[/url

No case to answer, x2.

There is, that's why they've been cited and will appear before the disciplinary panel.

Well i guess we will see if the much talked about bias towards Wigan has any truth. Whingeing Wires have a ready made excuse.....

Imo they do have a case to answer. I think carvel went in with a raised elbow .
and morley certainly went in late and very high. we will see what the rfl have to say. I personaly think they wont have the balls to ban both of them.
What will be will be and we will play whats in front of us.

I reckon Morley will miss out, it looked pretty bad and his disciplinary record is hardly squeeky clean.

I hope they both get banned.

I've tidied this thread up with many posts moved to the petty arguments thread I set up. Keep on Topic here ta.

Two matches and one match respectively

If there not banned wire win by 10 if they are banned wire win by 2

Considering our poor record at Halliwell Jones Stadium you should be expecting better than that surely?

Carvell has been charges with a grade c offence which carries a 2 - 3 match ban.

Morley has been charged with a grade B offence which carries a 1 - 2 game ban.

Thats where i got 2 matches and 1 match respectively from. If either of them get away without a ban i would think they have been very lucky.

www.therfl.co.uk/~therflc/superl ... p?id=16589

www.therfl.co.uk/~therflc/superl ... p?id=16589

I'll be amazed if the RFL have the backbone to do anything about it, they both deserve to be banned but really cannot see it happening.

Carvell's was a bad one imho. I think the fact that he looked at the man coming in and raised the arm, give a suggestion of intent, whether this was a deliberate elbow is another matter, but there was an intent to raise the arm and this went into a dangerous position.

Morley's was a bad one too, there was more than enough time to relax the arm imho and I think it was a definite case of making your presence felt, but badly timed (and aimed - if had been with the shoulder it may not have seemed so bad)

That said, I'd rather them both play, should be interesting.

Fully agree.

If Wire were playing Salford then probably, but the game of the season so far?? No chance.

How on earth was Carvell's worse than Morley's!! Morley came in late, with a stiff arm, on someone without the ball. Ok, you could say he was commited, but Morley made no attempt what so ever to bring his arm back in, it was out, and straight. Carvell on the other hand did the sort of thing Fozzard does every week.

i only saw carvell charging elbow he shud get banned like but i dowbt it anyway would like them both 2 play so if we beat them so wire done make any excuses that y they have lost

Like it was mentioned earlier it was worse than what Mathers did to Demetriou and he got red carded, Carvell knocked Jackson clean out leading with the elbow, if that isn't at least a one match ban I don't know what is.

Both were bad attempts at tackles/decapitation and should be properly punished by the rfl.
I actually want warrington to field a full strength team as I feel they're the team to beat this season and I'd like to see ho we measure up against them so far

personaly i would like to see a fair and equal outcome to the disciplinary. if that mean a ban then so be it .

Either way I am confident of beating Wire. We need someone to keep an eye on Louis Anderson because he will be trying to play dirty with Sam all night to put him off, somone needs to give him a slap if he does.

Sky will want them playing and as we know what Sky want Sky get.

All of you saying theres no way they are going to get banned are going to be very happy tomorrow.