never heard such a one sided commentary. well done to Saints, but I will not be listening to him again,

Didn't go to the match, in fact made kick off 10 mins late.


However, that commentary was terrible.


Totally one-sided.


Thaler is a disgrace too.

Pathetic ref.



Well done Stains though. Played to the end.

Thaler was diabolical in that 2nd Half, messing up the tackle count nearly cost Saints the match.

And would it kill him to award a penaty against Wigan for interference at the PTB, it was almost every tackle there was a flop or hands in.

Hope Thaler doesn't ref the Semi.

I think your heart is talking not your head both sides had some dodgy decisions

Overall we had the chances in the 2nd half to get that score ahead we didn't just like saints didnt in the first half

I though mossop and Flanagan were excellent no more than a handful of wigan games between them

Ive got to say i cant remember a match where saints have not made a real break the whole game we had the chances we didnt take them but its good to be up there and competing

3 posts and 2 blaming the ref

Refs have an impossible job now, the game moves so quick and with players adopting the football mentality of milking penalties whenever they can it's becoming silly for the refs.

As for the game, well played both teams, either could have won, though no team deserved to lose really after the effort they both put in.

Thaler was shocking towards both teams.

From a saints fan here, unlucky. That could have gone either way and I thought at 6-4, if we got a kickable penalty, a draw would have been the fair result.

See you at old trafford

Yep, Old Trafford would be a fitting re match. We missed too many chances.

Wembley is first well we can hope

i wonder if stevo has creamed all over eddie boy did that man
whant eastmond to do something special tonight
great game dissapointed we didnt win but also pleased with
what i saw.

In London, so couldn't make the game. Fair play to both teams - they gave everything in difficult conditions. Saints just got the run of the green when it mattered but credit to them, they kept coming.

As for Hemmings - he reached new lows tonight. He's an embarrassment. An embarassing standard of commentary - the amount of mistakes he makes is unreal. But also an embarrassing level of bias - I lost count of the amount of appaling incidences of favouritism. The ridiculously clear Gilmour 'no try' was the clincher at the end - 'That's a try, that's a try!!' (orgasm).

In fairness Wigan did miss too many chances.


You cannot pin all your hopes on defence as we did.



Lulu is a 9 not a 7. We realistically need a 7 and a 10.


If the management team are so retarded as to not see this then we are destined to lose again and again.

you've got Phil Clarke

You have never heard Phil Clarke then eh?

To be fair he scored when it mattered apart from that he did nothing BUT he did win the game, thats more down to our lack of composure in teh second half though

You do know there will be 6 other clubs in the playoffs don't you?

Listening to Phil Clarke drone on and on almost makes me wish I was deaf!

He's a bit old now to play either 9 or 7. He retired a while ago .

Yes but they will bottle it.

He soon shut up after that last try

True, but given the declining standards in Super Dooper League, I'm sure he could do a job at prop...............

Sickening to lose that game.

We had them and let them off the hook with far too many errors and forced passes that we didnt need to make. All we needed was 5 drives and a kick and play for field position and be patient.

Our defence was awesome though. On a dry track Eastmond wouldnt of got that try but full credit to Saints they knew they would get the chance to win the game if they hung in there.

Eddie now behaving like an excited 3 year old, complete tool. My cat knows more about rugby.

Hemmings is a c*nt. Id email Boots & All and challenge him to justify it but that would give the smug pleasure in his antics. He is a disgrace and the sooner Sky sack him the better.

Regardless of whether Eddie is biased or not.

He cant commentate for sh*t! Everytime he was commenting on a player he got the name wrong. At times even Steveo sounded like he'd had enough of him!