Yes, that decision before half time was an absolute farce and will no doubt be blamed. But Dobsons first half long ranger was a try for mine. Saw it 6 or 7 times on the replay under the stand.
In the end, losing possesion time and time again cost us that game. Error rate was horrendous

the same accroding to humberside these thing always even themselfs out, great game, great teams, great fans.

I had him for 1st try too

oh dear !!

Another defeat next week against the bst team in the world!

We are playing Melbourne?!

No better, the mighty wire

No better, the mighty wire

It makes me feel slightly better if that is the case. How he let them play the ball after the hooter, God only knows. You wonder what goes through the refs heads at times.

Should be a nice easy run out for our boys, a good warm up for the HKR game. Looking forward to 2 pts

LMFAO

Absolutely shocking decision by all accounts. But not a good enough reason as to why we lost. We lost because we had no idea in attack and kept losing possesion. Simple as that

did the hooter go before the tackle was made?

yes

The hooter ? The ref ?, who else could be at fault?

Maybe the 17 players - I know its a radical thought but it could just be true.

I heard the floodlights were a bit bright - maybe thats it. - Its Whelans fault.

If you actually read the thread you would see that No-one is blaming the hooter or the ref, too many knock ons lost us the game.

All these wire fans suddenly crawl out the woodwork now we lose a game, Internet must have been down for 4 or 5 weeks in Warrington

The hooter went as the tackle was made. Why don't they do what they used to do a blow the hooter when the ball is dead. But that was one of the worst reffing decision I've ever seen.

We weren't robbed but I don't think we deserved to lose tonight. Silverwood was for both teams.

Everything is rosy in the HJ garden at present now that Che Smith has shipped out the bad blood. (and got paid for it as well)



Is it a coincidence that our problems have gone north 10 miles ?

We've won 4 on the bounce, still in the CC, comfortably beat our fiercest rivals at Murrayfield, playing miles better rugby and just narrowly lost to top of the league.

Your problems must have gone to St Helens?

Youre probably right but give him time to work his magic - expert team divider

tonights match was tough enough in the conditions hard for both teams,if wigan loose fair and square i can accept it,but silverwoods performance in the first half was a complete disgrace.

His overall performance was a shambles.

You do realise you're don't you?

Decision was the turning point IMO. Diff between 12-0 just after half time and 12-6. Even with Hull KR 18-12 in front, if you take that sham of a try off we wouldn't have played the panic football we did.

That said our handling errors were back to their best. How many times did we knock on at dummy half, never mind off passes?!!

Although the decision was bad we had more than emough time to rectify it and full credit must go to Hull KR.