buy one player from one of our rivals in super league tomorrow who would you choose? why do you think they would add to what we've got?

Mozza,

for obvious reasons.

saying that i am more than happy with what the lads are doing right now.

Graham

best in the league

There's noone in the team that I would want to replace TBH.
I agree with Graham though. If he came to us he would also weaken St Helens

Dream on mate

James Graham
Kyle Eastmond

I would have Moz over Graham in an instant.

IMO there is far more to being a Prop than just gaining meters. Moz is the whole package and will never go hiding.

Eastmond.

until he retires in 2 maybe 3 years

graham could be around for a decade.

Not for me. A young Morley maybe but he turns 33 next month.

Morley gives away too many stupid penalties for me.

My vote to.

Morley? no ta. Couple of years ago maybe, but wouldn't go to the effort of signing him now.

Eastmond and/or Graham would be my choices.

Graham speaks for himself. As Tommy moves more and more towards the hooking role, Eastmond, I think, would be superb playing alongside Sam, plus he could fit in almost anywhere else in the backline. He's got pace to burn, a rugby head on him and a great kick.

Graham going to the NRL is a foregone conclusion, I feel. Eastmond going to RU I'm less sure about, especially given Lee Smith's nightmarish time there. While Eastmond hasn't got a long-term contract with Saints, I'd be drawing up plans to talk to him at the first opportunity.

Mathers

Again,dream on mate.

Heart says Morley

Head says Graham

James Graham for my money is a very good player. He makes the yards and puts in a decent shift in defence.

I just do not think he is worth the hype personally

If i am being Honest i would just want more from him. Saints fans will disagree but he goes hiding when the going gets tough. The game against us was a prime example.

Dont get me wrong i am sure somone will show me that he made X amount of yards and X amount of tackles ad thats fair enough.

But i want somone who will (sorry for the cliche) put there body on the line. Someone who will make the big plays at the times when the chips are down and all is against you. Mozza will do this, Graham will not.

Being as this is a hypothetical argument and (ATM) is all pure fantasy, i would have Ade over ANY prop in the league. The bloke has the respect of the whole RL community in both hemispheres. That counts for a lot in my book.


Also Graham is Tart

Says who?

Graham would give us 10 years service

Jesus H

This is a silly chit chat between Wigan fans making up Dream Team signings for OUR club.

Quit with the eye rolling and pee of back to where you came from.

Whilst i care about Petero's comments (as i also hold him in very high regard as a Pro) they are not the be all and end all of this argument

it is all a matter of opinion, and you have read mine.

Eastmond

I think it would be Eastmond for me as well - just one of those players who excites and as that bit of magic about him.
Added bonus of severely weakening our major rival.

Although position were I see we are short is hooker but dont know if I would take any hookers from super league.

Any takers on Briersicon_wink.gif

i'm sure binmen would take him