Don't rate him myself.

Thoughts?

You'll be hammered for such comments, but for what it's worth I agree. He's a plodder. Couldn't break wind.

Surely a wind up?

No, serious.

Not playing as well as last year but then guys like Prescott and Mossop have stepped up so he's not really had to. He showed how good he can be in the St George game when he was immense and I expect his form to pick up again in the big games.

I'll admit this season hasnt been his best, but he puts still in a shift every match. He's a grafter, gets through his work without any fuss. I honestly cannot remember the last time he knocked on. I'd rather have Andy Coley in my team than out of it, lets put it that way

This!

Coley is a good, honest, hardworking Prop Forward and thats what every team needs. He was quiet superb against St George and I expect his from will pick up once the business end of the season begins.

Him and Prescott set the platform for our play-off win at Leeds and then the GF win against saints.

i think you can tell he's coming to the end of his career. Different players have different shelf lives for lack of a better term. Guys like Morley etc are seemingly able to go on till their mid 30's with ease but for others the end comes much sooner.

Having said that, he's still doing a solid job and hopefully will shift into top gear for one final push come the season end. Overall he's been a very good signing for Wigan.

Andy Coley beasts in both attack and defence like no other player we currently have (Hock excluded).

He hurts people in when running the ball and is almost cruel in defence.

The best prop for the last two years for my money, i would not swap him for many others in SL.

If we had him at 25 he could have been a club legend.

He certainly wouldn't put a coat on a dog.

Nosey parker.

For the record neither have I....................................................................yet

One season too many for Coley I think.

Nah, drivvel!! Coley is solid, his first season i never noticed him but in 2009 and 2010 he was superb. he's seemed to stand out more in our big games ie St George and Good Friday this year.

Coley is a beast of a man. From Salford away 2009 he has been awesome for us, another unsung hero for me.

Real strange one for me. When he first signed I thought he was awful, always 3rd man in the tackle, never breaking a tackle, always losing the ball. Then we went to Salford and he had a blinder against his former club, and we were laughing and saying why can't he put that type of performance in every week. To his credit, he has and I see him as one of our most consistent if unspectacular props.

If you had to rate our props what would you go for?
For me :

1. Mossop
2. Fielden
3. Coley
4. Prescott
5. Lima (I still like him though and this is not slagging him off, just I think the others are better.)

How dare he not the length of the pitch from the kick off.....

Hard to tell without seeing Fielden play this year, some of his performances last year were sensational.

But Mossop has been the pick of the bunch who've played with Prescott 2nd up.

I can't quite believe this thread!

It Boggles the mind

I blame Finch

What a load of poop this thread is

Andy Coley is very underrated IMO and there are plenty of overrated players in Super League.

No disrespect to Salford but I often think opposition fans in particular have this pre-conceived idea about him that he simply is an average prop and was the best of a bad bunch at Salford. This is were he spent the majority of his Super League life. I think this way of thinking has followed him to Wigan and yet his form in 2009 and particularly last year has deserved higher plaudits and more recognition.

For me, our best prop in 2010.

I hope this thread is a wind up because if it is not then I just don't understand threads like this - we won the GF last year - we are joint top this year (with a game in hand) and still player get slagged off. Go figure!

For mine Coley has done a very good job for the team in the last two seasons - even this year he has still done a solid if unspectacular - what more do we need? All champion teams have the grafters, if he is a plodder then let us hope we can find another plodder when he finishes.