Full super league level is a totally different game from the under 18s and 20s. Some players develop a lot later and there are some kids that look great in the age groups and are tipped for stardom and it never really happens.

I would love Saints to have some of your young forwards but I am delighted with Lomax, Gaskell, Wheeler and Makinson. As for Foster there are some real weaknesses in his game which I am not sure will ever be addressed.

Although I have to take you to task on the "maybe we would take Lomax" quote. You would have him in a heartbeat !!!!

i wish you had foster, he is nearly as bad as sean day. good kicker both of them but crap apart from that

If Foster couldn't kick he be struggling to have a squad number at saints never mind a starters spot.

Well that's stopped all that nonsense about Wigan getting Wheeler thank the lord.

I agree.

Just thought id re-open this discussion, with the way the 2 teams are going i think a few people (myself included) may have changed there minds.