We've all been keen to see Carmont stay for one more year. Personally I'd love to see Coley stick around for another year as well. He has been a solid prop for Wigan and doesn't seem to suffer many injuries. Like Carmont he's a bit of an unsung hero. Keeping him for another year would certainly keep competition for places amongst the younger players like Mossop and Crosby.

What do you all think?

True. Good job there are a couple of stadia being built barely 20 miles apart.....

perfectly put



no matter what people seem to think of Coley we are a far greater side when he's on the field - he is one of our most important players both on and off the pitch.

Indeed. A proper prop forward who is vital to the team.

However in the past weeks on here it would seem he's overrated and on the wane - therefore he must be rubbish and we should just get rid and sign Cross.

Andy is indeed a qualified Quantity Surveyor, I studied with him at the old Warrington Collegiate Institute on Winwick Road before he went to LJMU to do his degree, me to Salford to do mine. As has been said by others - hes a top lad is Andy

Hopefully he'll decide to sign on for another year. He's not been as consistent week in week out this year but you always know he'll produce the goods in the big games. He's a tough player and a leader and he'd be a loss.

In an ideal world I'd like to see Coley, Carmont and Deacon all stay on next year. I think as time rolls by we need to start giving the 3 of them the odd week off but if we manage that right they'll be as good as ever.