I think he has only named a maximum of three from each team. Although I would also have Harrison before Westwood and Lynch before Scruton. Its a very strong pack, shame about the three quarters.
I would go with;
Widdop
Briscoe
Bridge
Shenton
Hall
Sam T
Kyle
Graham
Roby
Mozza
Ellis
Burgess
Lockers
McGuire
Joel
Peacock
Sinfield

famous amos appears to be a bit of an obsessed buffoon. I'm sure he isn't representative of Wigan fans in general though.

I think it's hilairous that they all keep saying

"This will be a big test"
"This will be a big test"
"This will be a big test"

Etc.

15 of the players are from Catalans so it's basically England v a team bottom of Super League by four points.

They point to France giving England a test in the four nations but a, Catalans were in good form going into that and b, England were truly dreadful more than France playing well.

If it's not a big walk over McNamara should be sacked straight away!

I'm looking forward to it as I imagine the bookies will price it up as England -40.

He wasn't my first choice but thats silly

Widdop's being picked for his potential and to mark him as English for the future. Exactly the right thing to do. I'm sorry but the quality of English SL full backs is so absolutely dire when compared to the best Australians this selection makes a lot of sense. I just wish we had a couple of NRL centres who could play for England as well, as again lets be honest Shenton/Bridge is not exactly a combination to make anyone's defence worry.

BTW if Flanagan continues to make progress he'll probably be in the mix by the end of the year too. Having half your pack (Ellis, Burgess, Morley and Flanagan) with NRL experience would enable England to play a half-decent defensive line. I'm not suggesting that Burgess ball in hand will be much different to now, but his ability to read the play will be a heck of a lot better.

When people bagged individuals last year they were half right - the real problem (apart from some odd positional choices by Smith) is that our players simply don't face the quality of attack the best in the NRL can offer. As a result they really struggle to read it. Part of the reason we were solid down Shenton/Hall's wing was because that was where Ellis was stationed. If we could be as solid on both flanks we might at least be defensively sound.