'"

agreed. what woundme up the most was that he liked to 'talk a good game' on the field, but had an inability to do himself what he expected eveybody else to do for him.
he also had a touch too much show pony about him for me. he also flapped when under pressure.

overall - behind a good pack, hes fine. but then again, behind a good pack, MOST halves look good !

If he was willing to defend he would fit in perfectly with Sam at 6 and Tommy/Riddell at 9.

It would be a gamble to take him on for another season but I would rather see us do this than go with Tommy again in the halves next year. I think Tommy is brilliant and I hope he finishes his career at Wigan but not as a half back as it is holding us back by Noble persisting with his limited game in the halves which I think in the long run is going to do no favours to Sam Tomkins.

id rather see craig smith back!

Doesnt matter, Smith doesnt want to go back to Superleague, its well known that his agent is trying to get him a contract in the NRL.

Good.