Agreed, Complete Shambles !!!

no one said that did they what was said was he was in a better position 5yds away and facing the player than your fans 100yds away and looking from the back of the player.

I don't know if it was the correct decision but he was in a far better position to see it than you or I.

However you and I could hear that the referee was wrong with the half time decision.

Unfortunately we're talking about the referee and not what was a great game of Rugby League.

Not at all, but he was the best positioned to give it!

There is no disputing that the Hooter had gone before he played the ball however & Silverwood saying he dind't hear it is a disgrace!
As said by other posters one of the Touch judges should have stayed their ground and said that the Hooter had gone.

Great game, both teams played well for 55 mins or so until the 2 HKR tries around the Hour mark and Wigan seemed to go to pieces.

Dobson's kicking game was the difference and his early kicks on plays 3 & 4 in the second half was great play and something our halves couldn't "Think" to replicate.

Ultimately this led to late charged down kicks on last tackles that changed the game!

that dobson one shouldnt of been given but the one early on where he slid about 10 meters was a perfect try. our own individual lack of brains and composure lost us the game- we where camped on hull krs line for the majority of the second half- cookes try was the luck of the day, sometimes they go for you sometimes they dont and a one on one tackle missed by carmont changed the complexion of the game, there was not much between them two teams last night.

im sorry, but the missed GC tackle was purely down to noble.
GC isnt fit, and can be exploited around the outside. nobby could have given him a day off, but chose to play him despite him being exploited the week before. KR know this and took advantage.
poor coaching.
other than that KR defended superbly and deserved their win.
dobson ran the 2nd half - wtf did nobby say at half time ?? wtf didnt anybody attack his legs ???