IN

BM's own honest decision and choice.

OUT.

In.

In. The fact that his record is much the same as TR's shows that our problem doesn't lie on the coaching side. I'm not going to say where I think it lies as I'm now too old and fragile to cope with another of gf's marketing rants.

Anybody suggesting BM should go needs to consider how that will address the real weaknesses, like our lack of squad depth, the lack of players who can control a game, the over reliance on hard working but rather limited forwards.

BM plays a fairly basic game plan, but realistically that's all he has open to him. If I were selecting the side I'd have wanted to drop Sharp, Gafa and Dorn, but that's not going to happen because there's nobody to replace them with. We lack a strong running second row, except Clubb, who seems to be switched between their and centre depending on need.

These things will not change by getting rid of BM.

Very wise


IN...but only because I believe in continuity and the lack of a decent replacement being available.

Can a mod turn this into a poll? I have a feeling many will be scared to criticise McDermott because of the reaction they may recieve on here.

Scared? WTF of? A visit from the man himself......

Brian McDermotts record since July 8th, 2006.
Won - 28
Lost - 36
Drawn - 3

The wrath of the delusional posters on here satisfied with mediocrity who will probably accuse them of being in a clique with me.

No: for the simple reason it's a pathetic Y/N question without recourse to all the other parameters required, bit like setting up a poll asking whether Lister is in a clique or not

Go on...I dare you

The OP said he didn't want a discussion though and I agree with him as the discussion has been done before and will be done in the future. Simple question, "do you want BM at the club next season?"... Various parameters all considered...

IN, just. Though the emergence of a credible alternative might change my mind.

Answers still no as people can and are answering on the thread if they so feel they want to with riders attached if desired.

We could possibly do better.
We could undoubtably do a hell of a lot worse as well.

IN

IN.

We had one of the supposed best coaches in the game for 3/4's of a season, and that season was even worse than this ever will be.

Lots needs fixing around the club, can't honestly say that removing BM would be top of the agenda

I agree. But if he goes we should go for John Kear, he is able to make nothing go a long way.

Misery

IN

but get in another attacking coach.

Definately IN - i dont think another coach would have got any different results considering the depth of squad we have and the run of injuries

IN!

Brian Mc is the main reason why we have been able to get players from up North.

Mick Manyn is not a valid argument DSWG

This seasons haul:
Ben Kaye
Jason Golden
Luke Gale
Mick Nanyn
Matt Gardner
Sam Thompson
Ryan Esders

From this list the only one who has performed consistently to a high level is Jason Golden.

Are we becoming the last chance saloon and more importantly, if a "bigger" club came in for Golden....would he stay?