Quote ="PC Plum"Purdham and Randall are outstanding players and would be welcomed to any SL side.
Dorn can be good, can be bad but what’s his position ?
Melling good player but what’s his position ?
Clubb, Howell and Temata decent standard but the latter injury prone and currently injured.
Ward, love him but he has had his day and is not big enough to make any impact in the front row.
Agreed on the overseas players, hopefully more Randall than Robinson.
O’Callaghan, well you couldn't be further from the truth, defensively inept.
Krasniqi, yes totally agree, he looked great and I have high hopes for him.
The pick of the rest are average Wilkes, Gale, Ellis and Golden and I hope the loanees Ambler and Burnett offer significantly more options.
Bolger, Sarginson, Bryan, Caro are young and raw and nowhere near good enough just now.
Williams shouldn’t be anywhere near the pitch.'"
Dorn's position is FB, no question about that.
O'Callaghan is victimised I think with being labelled as 'defensively inept' he's a young winger, playing outside normally Clubb, we all know about Clubb's defense, he's young, he runs out, so does Clubb, they need someone there like Purdhum to sort them out, then they will be fine.
I couldn't be more against thoughs players as average,
Gale has shown that on his day he can be very good, with the right players around him playing to their abilities, his kicking can be very accurate, he is a very good player, just look at Hull KR away (last season?)
Ellis, our best recruit of last season i think, came on as hooker and looked lively and controlled the team while BMc messed with Randall putting him at 7, he is quick and can pass a ball.
And Golden, how you can say he is average is completely ridiculous, he may not run the ball up much, but in defense he is a complete workhorse, for someone who isn't that big, he tackles, and tackles, he doesn't miss many, and normally is right up there with tackles made in the league.
For these points, i can't value your opinion on players much,
